Monday Morning Insights

Photo of Todd

    Why and how successful leaders get derailed

    Why and how successful leaders get derailed

    Here is part of an interesting article from It’s not starting well that counts, but ending well. Leadership "derailment" occurs when a leader, who had the ability and opportunity to accomplish more, ends up fired or demoted or simply fails to succeed at the level for which he was called and gifted.

    Researchers at the Center for Creative Leadership attempted to identify traits and behaviors associated with leaders who derail. Their studies showed that successful leaders were very similar in some respects to those who derailed. Most were visionaries, had strong technical skills, had a string of prior successes, and were frequently viewed as "fast-risers" in their organizations. While every leader had both strengths and weaknesses, the research indicated six basic clusters of flaws in the leaders who derailed:


    1. Problems with interpersonal relationships. This was reflected in: (a) overambition ? alienating others on the way up, or worrying more about getting a promotion than about doing the current job; (b) Independence ? being a know-it-all, or isolating oneself from others; (c) abrasiveness ? bullying, insensitivity, or lack of caring; and (d) lack of composure ? being volatile and unpredictable toward others, often under pressure.

    2. Difficulties selecting and building a team. This was seen in: (a) careless selection, cronyism, or choosing a team in one?s own image; (b) being dictatorial with team members; (c) not resolving conflict among team members; and (d) being a poor delegator.

    3. Difficulties in transitioning from the technical/tactical level to the general/strategic level. This involves: (a) folding under the pressure of the ambiguity and frustrations of higher levels of leadership; (b) not being able to overcome complexity, but becoming mired in tactical issues or detail, or coming up with simplistic agendas; and (c) failing to make the mental transition from doing to seeing that things are done. The most gifted athletes rarely make good coaches. The best violinist will not necessarily be the best conductor. Nor will the most productive salesman necessarily make the best sales manager. It is critical to distinguish between the ability to do and the ability to lead the doing, two very different capacities.

    4. Lack of follow-through. This reflects: (a) lack of attention to detail, which creates a trail of unresolved little problems and disorganization; and (b) moving too fast, which frequently results in not really finishing a job or leaving people dangling due to unmet promises.

    5. Overdependence. This includes: (a) staying with the same mentor or supervisor until people wonder if the leader can stand alone; (b) losing a mentor or supervisor who had previously covered up or compensated for the leader?s weak spot; and (c) relying too much on a personal strength such as a skill, natural talent, or raw energy.

    6. Strategic differences with management. This involves: (a) the inability to persuade one?s superiors concerning a particular position; or (b) the inability to adapt to a supervisor with a different style.

    While there are other reasons for derailment (e.g., illegal or unethical actions) the above six were prominent ones. Three of the flaws ? difficulties in selecting and building a team, difficulties in transitioning from the technical to the strategic, and lack of follow-through ? were most strongly related to expected future derailment.

    Any comments?  How does this relate to your work in the church?


    Like this story? Get MMI in your Inbox Every Monday Morning!


    if you want a Globally Recognized Avatar (the images next to your profile) get them here. Once you sign up, your picture will displayed on any website that supports gravitars.

    1. Chris Rosebrough on Wed, January 12, 2011

      You forgot the most important two.

      1. Bible Twisting - ripping verses out of context in order to create the illusion that the Bible is Guide Book for Living so that you can have your best life now.

      2. False Doctrine

      It doesn’t matter how good your leadership skills are or if you build the greatest team on the planet, if your not rightly handling God’s word and are instead teaching false doctrine you’re just sending people to hell.

    2. Barb Ezell on Thu, January 13, 2011

      Helpful, THX for the post. . .
      I think putting peacemaker or bridge builder into the job description & personal character goals, can help compensate for many of the interpersonal snaffu’s of working among broken people in a broken world.

    3. Page 1 of 1 pages

      Post a Comment

    4. (will not be published)

      Remember my personal information

      Notify me of follow-up comments?

    Get MMI in your Inbox Every Monday!