HOME | CONTRIBUTE A STORY! | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES OF INTEREST | CONTACT ME

A Pastor on “Why I Don’t Like Church”

Orginally published on Monday, January 23, 2006 at 6:21 AM
by Todd Rhoades

Preacher_1Remy Deiderich and I share a concern.  We've talked and debated it here at MMI many times over the last few months, but I think Remy does a great job in describing what happens when a church is not balanced.  He writes:

I've had 30 years of church experience; from megachurch to small church to house church. I've tried different size churches because I thought the size of the church might have a lot to do with the quality of the church. But after seeing that all structures (large and small) have their weakness, I decided that quality of a church has more to do with its attitude than its size.

One mistake that churches often make is in thinking that their purpose is to dispense information. In their mind they have the truth, and since Jesus said that truth sets us free, then all they have to do is educate the ignorant with the truth of the Bible.

But that simple mindset starts a snowball effect of legalism and hurt. This kind of thinking implies that we (those with the truth) are right and everyone else is wrong. People need to listen to us because we have the truth. If people don't listen to us, they hate the truth and are bad. Because they are bad we can exclude them and openly ridicule them. See what I mean? This happens in churches all the time. And that's why I don't like church (at least when I see this happen).

Lots of people turn up at Cedarbrook after experiencing some kind of church abuse. I've heard all kinds of awful stories about how churches have treated people who didn't believe right or act right. I'm amazed that these people even consider returning to church.

The purpose of the church isn't to dispense information. The purpose of the church is to love the world like Jesus did. Jesus said that he didn't come to judge the world but to save it. He laid down his life for the world.

When the world sees us laying down our lives in order to serve others then they will know that we have the truth. They'll know that we have the truth because they will see that we ARE set free. We've been set free from our independence and selfishness allowing us to love others. When they see that, maybe then they'll listen to what we have to say. But I don't think too many people are listening to the church that is merely pushing information.

What do you think? 


This post has been viewed 677 times so far.


 TRACKBACKS: (0) There are 123 Comments:

  • Posted by Greg McLarty

    You are abosolutely correct in this.  My wife and I are always meeting and ministering the these hurt individuals.  As a holder of the truth,if I somehow think that I need the grace of God less than someone who is not in relationship with Jesus, I in trouble at the core of my faith.  My righteousness is not based anything that I can do.  Unfortunately that is the perception pre-belivers are receiving from a lot of churches.  That they are bad.  We MUST NOT FORGET what we have been saved from..

  • Posted by

    I am in agreement with the article 100%, I would like to comment that I beleive there must be a balance of what was presented with the fact that people perish for lack of knowledge.  The Body of Christ is to be matured by the teaching of the apostles.  In Acts we see the apostles did not cease teaching and preaching Jesus as the Christ(5:8) and that the new believers continued meeting house to house. Acts 2:42 tells us they continued steadfastly in the apostles doctrine.  There must be knowledge of the Gospel preached and doctrine taught.  How harsh was the Annias and Sapphira episode? But the motive and root of it all must be love.  Correction, reproof, rebuke, and instruction in righteousness is the Word to Timothy..we can’t escape it.  People today do not abide these teachings of the word, and I do agree people are being beat up with the letter of the law.  There must be balance.  Correction must be received as the Wisdom to make one wise. If we truly love Christ we will receive even correction with grace for we know it is love.  I have experienced the abuse personally from those who are self-righteous, that is what kills, there is no love in that word but self love.
    Self-righteousness bases my standing on it’s scale of balance not our Heavenly Fathers.

  • Posted by

    What I have come to believe is that the most powerful force in the universe is love, not truth, not knowledge, not churches, not people.....
    When we start choosing to love one another, no matter what church we belong to, the kingdom of God will be grow, just like in the book of Acts.

  • Posted by

    I have been save by the grace of GOD,now for over 20yrs. i was called to preach the word of GOD at the age of 21,And now at the age of 48,i have also seen and heard a lots about people getting hurt in and by the church,cause i was one of those people.But what happen to the church is the church has lost it real meaning. The english word church is the translation of the greek word (ekklesia)which means"called out"The church is the mystical body of christ.of which he is the living head and (regenerate)believers are the members. A church is a body of baptized believers gathered together by the holy spirit for the purpose of carrying out the principle and precepts of GOD’s word. But what happen now in a lots of our churchs they have lost sight in what Christ came to do,His love is not in many of our churchs,and everthing else is in,and were Christ love is not,much hurt come in.

  • Posted by David Dalton

    Our good brother states, “When the world sees us laying down our lives in order to serve others then they will know that we have the truth.” However, I see many civic groups doing the same thing.  Groups like the Masons, Mormons, and Jehovahs witnesses all belive in good works.  Let’s not through out all of the teaching about the blood of Jesus and sanctification in order to appease a society that is bent on self gratification and an, “I’m okay, you’re okay” philosophy.  If we could have been righteous enough on our own then Jesus need not have died for our sins.  He is ultimately the one being degraded when we don’t bring a balanced perspective to the equation.  So, I propose that we continue allowing the Bible to speak for itself and to preach that word in love with a broken spirit, that cries out to the lostness of humanity.

  • Posted by

    Wow...somebody’s got it right! I have nearly 30 years of church experience as well and have seen the same thing. There is however, one other thing that I would add. The other thing that people don’t like about church and that I hear used as an excuse more than any other reason is that “the church is full of hypocrites”. A hypocrite is someone that says one thing then does another. Too often that is the case in any and all churches. As Christians we must do what we say...we must live out our faith before people. We must love and serve all just like Jesus did.

    I remember one time when I was in youth ministry, I was really upset and complaining to the Lord that the kids just were not getting it. I was pouring the truth into them, but they were not changing the way that I thought they should; Jesus simply asked me “do you have the power to save and change lives” to which I had to answer no! He then said that is right; you love them and I will do the rest! That is exactly what we must do...we must love them and show them in a practical way the love of Jesus Christ!

  • Posted by

    As a minister I have experienced the abuse from many churches . The African American churches are no different, many of the pastors still have the belief because I have been a pastor/minister for 40 years what I say is the only truth you need to hear. As the associate minister I make it a personal crusade to greet every one personally and make them feel as thou they are apart of the body of christ that needs some maintance done in order to meet the standards of christ. I haven’t for got where I once was and because of Gods grace and mercy I am now in a position to praise God .
    What I try to teach to all I encounter is god is waiting on you to call him and he will answer .To ridcule any one is totally wrong Ask this question did God ridcule you when you were doing all the sinnly things ?
    May God Bless and for ever keep you in his arms
    Rev. Ronald F. Rucker

  • Posted by

    Thank you for the comments made today. Pastor Susan Hans has truth to share.  Thank you for sharing scripture references.  Indeed, Love is the one command given by Jesus that we all agree on… the greatest is LOVE.  My desire is to have wisdom (God’s wisdom) so that I will discern all the knowledge these men and women of God share with me on Monday Morning!  Thank you Brother Todd!

  • Posted by

    This article seems to regard truth as being only of secondary importance to love.  Seems to me like the author is pushing the pendelum to the other extreme.  The biblical balance is “speaking the truth in love.” Both are important.  Without love, the church slides into cold, sterile intellectualism.  Without truth, the church slides into warm, fuzzy emotionalism.  But where both are present, lives are changed.

  • Posted by Pastor Nick

    My wife and I spent six years in a church like this! There was so many things going on and hugs and love that it was masked, but every Sunday or Weds. night the message was intertwined that “we are the truth, or if you leave here, you are leaving God.”

    When we finally felt it was time to leave, it felt as though we had jumped from a plane with no parachute.

    That was a megachurch. We left and wound up in a smaller group of people (<200)and started to feel better. We had more opportunites to serve and we were not forced to get involved.

    Twenty years later I am pastoring a small church myself. My wife oversees the womens ministry and worship, not because she has to but because she feels that is where she belongs.

    Now we truly feel free! Free to worship, serve and follow Jesus wherever HE leads!

  • Posted by

    Greetings in the Name of the Lord!
    AS always another interesting article.  I am a pastor of a small pioneer work.  Have been in an assortment of lay ministry positions as well over the last 27 years.  Who is to blame - the bottom line is that there is so much sin permeating this society that we [pastors, counselors, lay leaders or just the common man] cannot see the ‘forest for the trees!’ Sometimes I become so frustrated because of these ‘kangaroo Christians’ or those who are involved in the newest denomination “Crisis Christianity” only use and abuse when needed.  After offering advice or counseling, they then turn around [because they refuse Godly advice] and blame those offering advice through the Power of the Holy Spirit for their failure. What to do.....The Apostle Paul wrote - pray always.  If we are truly called to the ministry that power of prayer will keep us.  Remember as we read in Luke chapter four (4) we pass over verse 2 and go straight to verse 3-13.  This battle is continual and will be finally over when He returns! As a note of encouragement, I read those wonderful writings of Moses. We haven’t changed, have we?  All must assume responsibility for our behaviors and telling people to accept responsibility for their actions is something in todays society (at least in parts if the US) is politically incorrect. - Jesus, as I recall, did not compromise, did He? 
    Maybe preachers and counselors should get away from that feel-good message, and as sure as “the lake of fire for those who are unwilling to declare God’s salvation”, we need to get back to the basics.  Sure we are saved through Grace,but the life of a Bleievr remains a daily task.  If The Father didn’t want our lives to mature through His Grace, He would have taken us the moment we accepted His Son Jesus as Savior to be with Him in Heaven.

  • Posted by

    I recently resigned from the church I served as pastor for nearly ten years.  We ministered to many who suffered church abuse and then came to our church for healing.  It was wonderful seeing these lives re-redeemed, if you take my meaning.  Then I was forced out by those who were afraid of the upward trajectory of the church.  Now what happens to those re-traumatized believers who need healing all over again?  Will they find it in another church or will they give up on church altogether.  One victim recently told me, “I still believe in the Kingdom of God.  It will grow in spite of the church.” His tone didn’t show much hope for the church.

  • Posted by

    Maybe I misunderstood the author’s intent, but I totally disagree with this article.  Yes, God is love, but God is also judgment.  As I think one person already said the pendulum needs to be balanced in the middle.  We are not to judge, God does.  We are to love those sent to us.  But, they are sent to us to hear God’s Word; His Truth.  We are called to preach God’s Word to those who haven’t heard it and to help others grow in relationship to God so that they, too, will carry His Light into the world.  We are to live in love, but we need to be hearers and doers of God’s Truth.  To do anything less is disobedience to God and displays a lack of reverence for God.

    Carolyn

  • Posted by Remy Diederich

    I was surprised that my blog article was in the Morning Insight on “Why I Don’t Like Church”.  Just to clarify a bit (for those who are concerned about imbalance), the preaching of Truth is obviously important.  But we’ve lost perspective and are undermining the very reason for our existence (preaching Good News).

    I think if we would scrutinize the typical evangelical church we’d see that we function like information saves us.  The love of God, shown in Christ’s death saves us.  God ACTED out the truth of his love. Truth became incarnate.

    That’s my point.  God didn’t just give us the information...I love you.  He showed us.  So preach away but back it up with more than a potluck after the service.  There’s no excuse for the thousands of people left in the church parking lot gutter (so to speak) because of the harsh condemnation they received in the church.

    We are often less the community of God and more a religious school.  Our notebooks are full of facts but our hearts are dry and lonely.  We can do better.

  • Posted by Barry Black

    I agree to an extent with your article.  After all, Jesus told his disciples that “by this shall all men know that ye are my disciples if ye have love one to another.
    However, in Ephesians 4, the apostle Paul certainly addresses the responsibilities of the church (particularly 4.11-16).  Part of that includes learning and being grounded in doctrinal truth (I believe you used the term “education").  We live in a day where churches focus more on a “feel good” atmosphere and neglecting to ground people in doctrinal truth.  That is why so many Christians are clueless as to what they really believe.  And that is also why so many are being deceived by Jehovah’s Witnesses, Church of Christ, Mormons and other cults.

  • The job of the leadership in the pulpit is to give the truth from the scriptures and to place it in today’s context. So many Pastor’s and Messianic rabbi’s are sugar coating the message for the bratty American public. If we look at history through the scriptures we see when God’s chosen people (And the Jews still are) would make mistakes He would chastise them. When the rabbi’s would follow the writings of the rabbi’s over the Torah they would get chastised. Now in Messianic Hebrews 13 it says (Heb 13:8 Yeshua (Jesus) the Messiah is the same yesterday, today, and forever.) So did God change to different standard today? And before you start going down that silly road of “were under grace” thing, first think this…was Adam and Eve under law or grace…was Cain and Abel under law or grace…was Noah and the world under law or grace? We need to get back to following the Messiah Yeshua (Jesus). When Christians divorce rate is higher than those of secular society. When pornography is in higher use than ever before. Gay marriages and gay clergy. When 86% percent of America says they are Christian but United States likely experienced its 47 millionth legal abortion at some point in 2005. When all this and much more is going on, we the people in the pulpit need to let ALL those in the USA and around the world know this. That this is the Titanic and there is an iceberg DEAD ahead.
    Those of us who call ourselves Believers need to look at our old Jewish brethren and learn from there mistakes. They were so rapped up in there own pre-laws (writing of the rabbi’s) that they could not even see there own Messiah. The Church needs to wake up and stop crying! It is simple if the Disciples did it, If Yeshua (Jesus) showed us how to do it, And the Father commanded us to do it forever (Or throughout your generations) than follow Messiah and not man made things.  The Lord wrote the whole bible every word, 66 books, 40 authors ONE GOD!

  • Posted by

    Been there, done that!
    Excellent article...I think what people are looking for in a church and what most of us are saying is, “Genuine christianity practiced in people’s lives, not just in a worship service.”
    It is easy to hide in a larger church setting and not see our personal responsibilities in relating to unchurched, unsaved, backslidden people.
    The necessary love can only come with a personal walk with God...the person who does so will not have to “drum up business"--people will come to them...they will see Jesus in us.
    I don’t know if our problem is that we are trying to convince other people of our positions and standing with God or if we are trying to convince ourselves that we are OK with Him...somehow we are missing the “affairs of the heart” and putting on a show.
    Church size, denominationalism (or lack of it), programs, even evangelism, preaching, teaching...none of it is the issue...the real issue is how is our relationship with God?
    If our relationship with God is intimate, personal, and real...the results will be right and His love (and truth) will flow from us into other people’s lives.
    God bless you and I pray that we will be genuine with God and ourselves, thus producing the genuineness with others.
    Matthew 7:18 says that a good tree does not bear bad fruit and a bad tree does not bear good fruit...the real issue is where are we rooted?

  • Posted by Tom James

    Thanks Remy for clearing up some of my concerns about balance. But there is still the issue with saying that any time a preacher preaches hard / passionately against sin that he is being “judgmental” and “mean-spirited”. I know that those are not words that you used but that seems to be the jest, at least the way many of the posts above have taken what you have said. The idea that we must “love” without any condemnation of sin just doesn’t seem to equate with my understanding of scripture.

    Yes, the greatest commandment is to love the Lord God with all that we are and the second is to love our neighbors as we love ourselves. But I am not convinced that boldly speaking the truth is not at times the greatest act of love we can perform. Jesus is the supreme example of love and yet we see Him calling the Pharisees “white washed sepulchers”. In other places He referenced people in equally strong language. I am not saying that I have liberty to call folks I don’t know or don’t agree with names, but I do believe that we must boldly proclaim the truth of God.

    My desire is to never purposely be offensive in the pulpit but yet I balance that with the knowledge that when the truth is preached that it often time offends those in sin. The church I serve gives me great freedom to preach in the pulpit and the reason for this I believe is because they know I love them.

    God bless!

  • Posted by

    I agree that the church is aware now more than ever, that we often times are guilty of being our own worst enemy.  And yes, American sub-culture has created some bizarre representations of what a Christian looks and acts like.  Watch Christian television for a while, or attend any one of hundreds of churches that have their own language. But to say it all boils down to a love that focuses entirely on acceptance is out of balance with scripture.  It’s too easy to site one verse to support this view, yet a little more challenging to take responsibility for being mature Christians who know when and how to speak the truth.  Jesus is a great model on speaking the truth in public forum regardless of popular opinion or tradition.  Love, accept, and speak the truth; all the while staying relatable, credible and responsible for the voice of the Church.

  • Posted by

    Unfortunately, this article gives the church very little edification It is obvious we are to love others, even when it is difficult.

    I think I will stick to the Word of God and not feelings, as to the remedy for a sin.

    2Ti 4:1 I charge you in the presence of God and of Christ Jesus, who is to judge the living and the dead, and by his appearing and his kingdom:
    2Ti 4:2 preach the word; be ready in season and out of season; reprove, rebuke, and exhort, with complete patience and teaching.
    2Ti 4:3 For the time is coming when people will not endure sound teaching, but having itching ears they will accumulate for themselves teachers to suit their own passions,
    2Ti 4:4 and will turn away from listening to the truth and wander off into myths.

    Luk 8:11 Now the parable is this: The seed is the word of God.
    Luk 8:12 The ones along the path are those who have heard. Then the devil comes and takes away the word from their hearts, so that they may not believe and be saved.
    Luk 8:13 And the ones on the rock are those who, when they hear the word, receive it with joy. But these have no root; they believe for a while, and in time of testing fall away.
    Luk 8:14 And as for what fell among the thorns, they are those who hear, but as they go on their way they are choked by the cares and riches and pleasures of life, and their fruit does not mature.
    Luk 8:15 As for that in the good soil, they are those who, hearing the word, hold it fast in an honest and good heart, and bear fruit with patience.
    Luk 8:16 “No one after lighting a lamp covers it with a jar or puts it under a bed, but puts it on a stand, so that those who enter may see the light.
    Luk 8:17 For nothing is hidden that will not be made manifest, nor is anything secret that will not be known and come to light.
    Luk 8:18 Take care then how you hear, for to the one who has, more will be given, and from the one who has not, even what he thinks that he has will be taken away.”

    Preach the Word!

  • Posted by

    I think that if we tried to be the body of believers, called out to exhibit the fruit of the spirit (what was the first of those again?....) then we would be more like the kind of church I think Remy wants to see us be.

  • Posted by

    I’m in total agreement with the ariticle. I believe the church does need to be be more balanced between it’s responbility to present the truth as they see it and their obligation to those who receive their presentation of the truth. I believe the church has left a trail of “abused” church members (I call them aborted church members) who because of the “attitude” of the church, have left the church, possibly never to return.  As a pastor for over thirty years, I look back at my own attitude toward the members of my church and of those who served on my staff and realize that I hurt members of my staff and church members in my pursuit to build a successful church. Most pastors that I know want to build a successful church..but at what cost? One respected pastor of a “mega” church said the main issue for the 21st church should be “church health” not church growth.  I believe we need a new definition of what constitues a successful church. A church is not necesarily healthy because it’s growing, or in a building program, on television, or any number of the traditional signs most look at to identify a healthy church. I believe the apostle Paul touched on this very issue when he admonished believer in I Corinthians 4:14-16 to be imitators of his life of “being a spiritual father” rather than just being a teacher..."a dispenser of truth”. I believe a church is healthy when people are receiving the love from leadership that has a true “spiritual fathering” heart and sees them as more than someone to fill a seat or a resource to help the church meet its goals of success. When asked the question by his disciple, “show us the Father”, Jesus was able to say, “when you have seen me you have seen the Father”.

  • Posted by

    I truly believe that you would have had the very same problem with Paul had you been in a church he pastored, or even Jesus, as he denounced the scribes, pharisees and publicans.  He called them fools and hypocrits.  The problem you have is not with the church, which I would remind you He purchased with His own blood, but with the word of God which we are commanded to preach and teach.  Paul tells Timothy, a young pastor, to preach the word, be instant in season and out.  Reprove, rebuke and exhort with all longsuffering.  In I Tim. 5:20 Paul tells Pastor Timothy; “Them that sin rebuke before all, that others also may fear.” The reason the world is as it is, and Christianity is as it is, is because people are not preaching the word of God as they are commanded.  Jesus said; “When the Son of man returns, will he find faith on earth.” In Jude we are told to “Earnestly contend for the faith once delivered the saints.” He will find many churches, and many professing Christians, but he will find very little Biblical faith, at least not the faith once delivered the saints.  You are not a part of the solution, you are indeed a part of the problem.  I was saved and grounded in a fundamental, ultra conservative Bible preaching, Bible teaching church, and I know thousands just like me who absolutely love the teaching and preaching of God’s word.  Is love important, absolutely, but it is a balance of Bible + love, not all love and then we will throw a little non offensive Bible in to go along with it.  God looks on the heart, but the only place man looks is on the outward appearance.  God finds both extremely important.  I would also ask the you do a in depth “Bible” study on legalism.  The Bible says that “The law is spiritual, but we are carnal.” The law has been done away with for justification, but not for holy living.  Remember, God said; “Be ye holy, for I am holy.” In Amos 3:3 God asks the question, “Can two walk together lest they be agreed.” We do not walk with God unless we walk as God commands us to.  Not for salvation, but for fellowship.  God also comments on modern day christianity when he says; “Having a form of godliness, but denying the power thereof.” Where is the power of God spoken of in this verse,,, it is in the godliness, or holiness God commands us to live in.

  • Posted by Dr. Ed Hill

    It is delusional thinking in a fallen world to ever think that any church could be what
    it should be!  Even those that get it mostly right have those areas in which they
    miss it...because it is a volunteer organiztion full of messed up people from the top down.  My gripe is with church hoppers and shoppers who never find the
    perfection they seek and flit from church
    to church, eventually settling for worship
    at home which is contra-biblical if it intentionally isolates them from community
    that is available in the “imperfect churches”. I speak as a pastor who has been
    financially devastated by a bad church
    experience, but even I have not written off
    church!

    That’s my stand,
    Dr. Ed Hill
    CrossPoint Church
    North Georgia

  • Posted by

    I to have seen this in the church, I have been a victim of it.  As a person who does a lot of street ministry, I have talked to, counseled and helped many others who have been victims as well. 

    YES, God is love! God is truth! God is Just, Holy and Righteous.  Love is not the ultimate, but only part of the whole.  With out truth what is love, or justice, or holiness, or righteousness? God is perfect and is all of the above and more.  Love does not conquer all, nor does truth, or justice, or . . . . .  But Truth in Love of a Just, Holy and Righteous God who gave his own son to pay a price we could not pay, now that goes a long way.

    I hate legalism, I have seen it in churches and what it does to people, I have felt the hurt it can cause.  On the other hand liberalism is just as bad as it soon becomes I’m OK, you’re OK, and things so watered down there is no truth.

    The truth is we have all sinned and come short of the glory of God.  The wages of that sin is death.  IF we are not new creatures in Christ we are under the condemnation of God, waiting for his judgment and execution of the punishment, eternal death.  This is the truth the whole truth. The love is that ONLY by grace are we saved through faith in Jesus (Yeshua) not by any works or man made laws. That God loved us that he sent his son to be the perfect sacrifice, the Lamb of God, and only through faith in him can we have eternal life.

    To speak the truth in love is to preach the gospel, that we are sinners teaching them what sin is, and how sinful we truly are in God’s eyes.  That because of our sin we deserve eternal death!  But because God loved us so much he made a way, he sacrificed his own son so that we could have eternal life through him.  Yeshua – Jesus gave himself a willing sacrifice so that we would not have to stand in judgment for our sins.  He is the way, the only way to have eternal life, the way to heaven.

    Legalism is a Jesus plus something else gospel and the bible is clear on that.  The liberalism of I’m Ok, you’re Ok is clearly not the truth of the Bible either.

    There is absolute truth, that truth is the Gospel of Jesus Christ.  Given in love; written in blood.  Speak the truth in love, give them the gospel.

    People do not care how much you know, until they know how much you care.  Show them you care by leaving the safety and security of the four walls of your church and do go out and tell them truth in love.

    Then once a person accepts the truth and Jesus as his savor, he can then be trained as a disciple. To be a believer and to be a disciple is to entirely different things, a believer believes, a disciple believes and acts on his faith.  Satan is a believer, he believes there is a God, Jesus and knows the Bible better that you or I, but he is not a disciple because his faith is not in Christ it is in himself.

  • Page 1 of 5 pages

     1 2 3 >  Last »
Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: