HOME | CONTRIBUTE A STORY! | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES OF INTEREST | CONTACT ME

image

UPDATE:  United Methodist Church Defrocks Lesbian Pastor

Orginally published on Tuesday, November 01, 2005 at 9:32 AM
by Todd Rhoades

Big news from the UM Church:  This from the Houston Chronicle:  In a denomination divided over the role of homosexuals in its ranks, a United Methodist Church court Monday defrocked a lesbian minister and reinstated a pastor suspended for denying church membership to a gay man…

The nine-member Judicial Council, the denomination's highest court, released its decisions after hearings last week at Houston's First United Methodist Church Westchase campus.

The council ruled that the Rev. Irene "Beth" Stroud of Pennsylvania had violated church law that prohibits "self-avowed practicing homosexuals" in the clergy.

It also reinstated the Rev. Edward H. Johnson, pastor of South Hill United Methodist Church in Virginia, who had been suspended by his bishop after refusing to add a gay man to the church membership roster.

The ruling against Stroud means the 35-year-old cannot return to her job as associate pastor of Philadelphia's First United Methodist Church of Germantown.

"I had tried to be emotionally prepared for that possibility," Stroud said. "The news still came as a blow."

Stroud said she plans to continue her job as a lay member of the church staff, teaching a confirmation class and assisting in worship services.

She will not be allowed to celebrate church sacraments, such as baptisms.

The decision "shows without question that, at this point in its history, the United Methodist Church practices discrimination against people like me, against gay and lesbian people who may be qualified for ministry but who are in relationship with a partner," she said.

In December, a church trial found Stroud guilty of violating denomination law. The trial was held after Stroud disclosed to her congregation in 2003 that she was "a lesbian living in a committed relationship with her partner," Chris Paige. She was removed as associate pastor, though she continued to work as a lay person.

In April, an appeals court overruled the decision.

The Judicial Council decision overturns the appeal. The vote was unanimous, with one member absent. Two members signed a statement saying they agreed with the decision but "deeply regret the outcome."

The case was heard in Houston because a lay member of the Judicial Council, Mary Daffin, lives in the area. She voted with the majority on both cases.

The ruling does not end the discussion about homosexual clergy, said the Rev. Thomas Hall, who argued the case against Stroud for the church's Eastern Pennsylvania Conference. But it does emphasize that churches and their clergy must abide by the rules of the denomination.

"Once the rules are in place, once we have voted, when the dust clears, we need to honor them," Hall said.

In the second ruling, the Judicial Council reinstated Johnson after Bishop Charlene P. Kammerer of the Virginia Conference removed him from the pulpit.

By a vote of 5-3, with one member absent, the council overturned Johnson's suspension. It determined that "the appointed pastor in charge has the duty and responsibility to exercise responsible pastoral judgment in determining who may be received into the membership of a local church."

Writing for the dissent, the Rev. Susan T. Henry-Crowe of Atlanta said that the church rules do not give pastors discretion to exclude people.

"This decision compromises the historic understanding that the Church is open to all," she wrote.

FOR DISCUSSION:  Any comments?


This post has been viewed 173 times so far.


 TRACKBACKS: (0) There are 19 Comments:

  • Posted by

    This would be a good enough reason for me to either not join or find another church.  How I love UCC!!!

  • Posted by

    I understand the ruling for the pastor who was living with the partner.  I don’t understand how one can turn away a person wanting to seek God’s grace.  It is not up to us as humans to determine who is to be a part of a body of Christ.  That is the work of God.  I have to agree with the other person who stated that I thank God for churches like the United Church of Christ.

  • Posted by

    Church membership does not make you a part of the body of Christ, salvation by grace does that.  I am in a Baptist church and I would refuse membership to someone who does not believe in baptism by emersion.  They would be welcome in all of our activities and services, but not as a member.  Would you allow an athiest to be a member?  No, they do not believe what your church does.  This is not a matter of being open or reaching out to gays, it is a matter of membership and following the rules set forth by the church.  Some may contend that these are mans rules and not God’s.  That is the difference between being a part ofhte body of Christ and being the member of a denomination or local church.

  • Posted by Jackson

    I think it’s impossible for a church claiming orthodox Biblical Christianity to allow a professing, practicing, and proud gay person to be clergy. 

    And “membership” is different from attendance.  I personally wouldn’t want to be a “member” in a church where you allow those practicing a way of life in opposition to clear Biblical teaching to be “members” as well.  Love is not just saying “oh it’s okay for you to do what you want to do.” Love without truth isn’t love, if you ask me.

  • Posted by Jackson

    I also want to clarify that I am a sinful person and I didn’t mean to give the impression that I’m not.  But I would expect someone at my church to call me on it if I were cheating on my wife or engaged in any sin as a way of life.  I’m far from perfect and I need people to help correct and guide me...not to tell me it’s okay to live any way I want and watch me slide farther and farther from a right relationship with God.

  • Posted by Bernie Dehler

    The issue of slavery (during the Civil War) split the major denominations (Baptist, Prebyterian, & Methodist), although some rejoined since.  Both sides appealed to the Bible.  Now it’s time for homosexuality.  This is a chance to seperate the wheat from the chaff… lukewarm to hot or cold.

    ...Bernie
    http://www.oneplace.com/ministries/247

  • Posted by

    You wrote, “This is a chance to seperate the wheat from the chaff… lukewarm to hot or cold.”

    I thought that was HIS job, not ours…

  • Posted by Bernie Dehler

    RE: Judging
    “I thought that was HIS job, not ours...”

    Jesus wrote to the church in Laodicea and told them that because they were lukewarm He would spit them out… disgusting to Him…

    He then gave an invitation to open the door to our hearts.  Scripture tells us to judge ourselves:

    1 Corin. 11:
    31But if we judged ourselves, we would not come under judgment. 32When we are judged by the Lord, we are being disciplined so that we will not be condemned with the world.

    Yes, Jesus will seperate the wheat from the chaff, in that we can’t judge hearts, but we can judge actions… and take a stand for rightousness.

  • Posted by

    This issue above all others always leaves me shaking my head in astonishment. Let’s cut to the chase: Both the Old and New Testaments are absolutely “crystal” in conveying God’s opinion of homosexualty. Those who practice the gay/lesbian lifestyle are unqualified for ministry. Period. Look up the scriptures--do they mean anything at all? It’s not about all of today’s PC drivel. And it’s not about judgementalism or legalism. It’s about the heart and mind of a holy God who hasn’t been the least bit bashful about what He thinks on the subject. See Romans for starters. What about “reprobate mind,” as defined by acts of homosexuality, is hard to understand? Does God’s word make a dent in these folks’ lives at all?  Do they even READ it? Do you want to minister? How about starting with some basic genuine repentence? Not the brazen public flaunting of an undeniably sinful lifestyle.
    God sacrificed his only Son for this stuff along with all the other stuff!

  • Posted by Bernie Dehler

    Hi Dave-

    I think a big part of the problem is the lack of holiness in today’s churches.  How many ‘wink’ at pre-marital sex? Sex is all over our movies… and sex sells… Do pastors see r-rated movies? How we need to be bold and not afraid to be counter-culture, rather than trying to fit into the culture.  Part of the problem is the way the gospel is being preached… as an add-on to enhance your life, rather than a repent and be born-again message… we need to preach living by the spirit rather than the flesh…

    ...Bernie

    Romans 8:2
    because through Christ Jesus the law of the Spirit of life set me free from the law of sin and death.

  • John Wesley might not roll over in his grave after all.

    The UMC is finally getting some Scriptural sense about them again.

    After all these years…

  • Posted by

    When God’s word is our standard things are so clear - I Tim. 3 and Titus 1 give clear requiremnts for those who desire to serve in the role of a pastor, we will be accountable to God for not sticking to these requirements.

  • Posted by

    Jesus said, “Love the Lord your God with all your heart and all your soul and all your mind, and the second GREAT commandment is like unto it - love your neighbor as yourself.  On these hang all the laws and the prophets.” Furthermore, he did not attach conditions to these commandments.  Therefore, we have no right to judge.  It is a sad day when the United Methodist Church goes contrary to the Gospel message with such a discriminatory ruling.  Remember, Jesus spent his time around people who were considered undesirable in his day as well.  Also, I’m a very happily married heterosexual Christian man, and my learning about relationships has come from healthy couples in BOTH heterosexual and homosexual relationships.  You can quote other bible verses to me all you want - all that I know about Christianity teaches me to be ACCEPTING of all people everywhere.  That is the hard work we have as followers of Jesus Christ.

  • Posted by

    Kevin, you write “You can quote other bible verses to me all you want - all that I know about Christianity teaches me to be ACCEPTING of all people everywhere.”

    I agree with your statement, anyone is welcome in my church, no matter what their sin. I will accept them, even if I do not necessarily condone everything they do. I will not ask them to “clean up their act” first. I believe the Holy Spirit will work that in their life. I will point them toward Christ, and toward His word, and I’ll be there to answer questions along the way.

    But if a Christian LEADER is living in what the Bible calls sin, and does so publicly, claiming that it is not in fact sin, then that leader is indicating that they do not put stock in the authority and inspiration of Scripture. In this case, I actually don’t think the fact that she is a lesbian is what disqualifies her! Her open practice of a life-relationship that runs contrary to the word of God, and more specifically, the inescapable conclusion that she therefore considers parts of the Bible to be in error, is the issue. (If my senior pastor stands up this Sunday and states that he has thought about it, and the books of James and Jude need to be removed from the Bible, then our church is going to make that an immediate issue and act!)

    If someone is “living in sin” publicly in ministry, it may be possible to restore that person, in fact it would be the preferable course of action, but if a person is saying that the Word of God is false, as is often the obvious issue in cases like this, then officially removing them from leadership simply confirms that they have ALREADY (de facto) removed THEMSELVES from Christian leadership. There are many “negotiables” in the Christian faith. The authority and inspiration of Scripture are not among them.

    For consideration, I offer this quote from a few years back from V.Gene Robinson, the openly practicing gay ECUSA bishop of New Hampshire, which I include word-for-word from his mouth.

    “Just simply to say that it goes against tradition and the teaching of the church and Scripture does not necessarily make it wrong, We worship a living God, and that living God leads us into truth.”

    Well, then what exactly DOES make something wrong?

  • Posted by Brian La Croix

    Kevin, you said:

    “You can quote other bible verses to me all you want - all that I know about Christianity teaches me to be ACCEPTING of all people everywhere.”

    What you may not see is that there is a HUGE difference between being accepting of PEOPLE and being acceping of IDEAS.

    Jesus accepted people all the time.  But you will never find any place where he condones sin.  And he accepted lots of people from different religious backgrounds.  But he never equivocated from his statement that the only way to heaven was through him.

    Jesus was tolerant of people, but not of ideas, beliefs, etc.

    My father-in-law is gay.  I accept him - I don’t accept his chosen (yes, I used that word on purpose) lifestyle.  He knows where we stand, and to his credit, he is very gracious about not discussing this in our home or around our children.

    I love homosexuals - but that doesn’t mean I have to accept what they believe about homosexuality.

    But one of the overlooked aspects of this story is that Ms. Stroud was in direct violation of the clearly written constitution of her denomination.  The ruling was only about that.  The battle will not go away any time soon, that’s for sure.

    Brian

    Brian

  • Posted by

    I thank the True and Living God for the number of people He has brought to this blog over the last 5 months or so, who are willing to stand for Truth, no matter what others think, say or perceive.

    I encourage those that believe homosexuality is not wrong (sinful) according to Scripture, to take the time and consider Who God Is.  His Charachter and Nature have not changed (nor will they).

    There are MANY ways which seem right to man BUT.....

  • Posted by

    Jesus did confront sin...the sin of sex outside of marriage. Consider the woman caught in the act of adultery.  He said He did not condemn her and TO GO AND SIN NO MORE! In other words stop sinning according to the Scripture’s direction. Even if same sex marriages become legal they will still be sin because God does not accept the practice of homosexuality. Yes, He loves the person but the acts are against the Written Word. Those who chose to continue to believe and live otherwise will be given over to a reprobate mind they will begin to accept lies as thought they were the truth.  You can’t change God’s commands...let His Word be true and every man a liar (if necessary).

  • Posted by

    I am a strong believer that God is also for the gays and lesbians. He died on the cross for them, just as He did for everyone. If my Pastor was involved in a relationship outside of marriage, he is no longer qualified to preach until the sin is repented of. Yes, it is a sin to live with someone outside of marriage, even for gay and lesbians. So, the same goes for gays and lesbians who want to be preachers and still live outside of marriage with their lover. If I was a Pastor of a church yet still living in sin, what example am I setting. Of course we all have sin in our lives, but we should always be repenting. If someone believes that what they are doing is right despite the Bible saying the opposite, that person should not be in a role of leadership within the church. It’s not about who the person is but about their life style that goes against what God tells us. Thieves should not be preaching, liers shouldn’t be preachering, murderers, slanders, and so on. Those who are living together outside of marriage are living in sin. Gay, lesbian, or straight. It’s not about discriminating against gays and lesbians. They are no different than the rest of us and God loves them all the same. Taking a leadership role in a church is a very serious thing, and it should be taken very serious. Those who are leaders will be accountable. Only those who are morally and spiritually sound in the word of God should be allowed to lead. The church is for sinners, and whenever a sinner is denied access to a church, the church will be accountable for that persons blood. Our church welcomes all kinds of sinners. In fact, our church is filled with them. They however, know that they are sinners and repent of there sins in order to keep the relationship between them and God alive.
    I know of a christian man who lived a gay lifestyle. One day God touched his heart, and he surrendered his life to Jesus Christ. He knew right away that he was living in sin. When he approached the cross with all his sins, worry, concerns, and fears, God lifted them all from his shoulders. He was no longer guilty. Like many other christians out there, he struggled with temptation, and would occasionally fall. But, he would always get on his knees and pray for forgiveness. As most of us know sin can sometimes be hard to turn away from. This man that I speak about is a very strong devoted Christian. He doesn’t have a label on him saying, I’m Gay! No, instead, he has a label on him that says, “God’s Property. Bought and paid for by the blood of Jesus Christ. Who dares to deny that before God. Be very careful how we judge, for the same way we judge others God will judge us. Sin is sin no matter the name given to it. All sin is equal. No sin is greater than another. The christian who occasionally tells a white lie is no better than a Christian who struggles with gay tendencies.

  • Posted by

    http://www.kjekk-student-kjonn.toyt3.com ^^^ http://www.analsex-full-jenter.toyt3.com ^^^ http://www.vergognoso-bionde-sudore.str0nz0.com ^^^ http://www.lovable-studentessa-schizzate-di-figa.str0nz0.com ^^^ http://www.porn-bilder-clitoris.pul4.com ^^^ http://www.strimma-tecknad-fitta.pul4.com ^^^ http://www.sperman-rinner-prostituerad.pu1a.com ^^^ http://www.dick-lek-samaiphone.pu1a.com ^^^ http://www.sentimentaalinen-aasialainen-humalainen.huor4.com ^^^ http://www.imela-beibit-tupla-penetraatio.huor4.com ^^^ http://www.lammasmainen-tytsyt-paskantaa.hu0ra.com ^^^ http://www.outo-lesbo-aasi-jotta-kita.hu0ra.com ^^^ http://www.ridiculous-fighette-sex.fott1.com ^^^ http://www.foto-gratis-tette-immense.fott1.com ^^^ http://www.good-looking-fighette-sesso.f0tti.com ^^^ http://www.gradito-signoreporche-azione.f0tti.com ^^^ http://www.viilein-tunne-neito.sexsipillu.com ^^^ http://www.ollilan-vaimo-masturbating.sexsipillu.com ^^^ http://www.spermakaskader-fontanorgasm.sexknulla.com ^^^ http://www.nakna-larare-remsa.sexknulla.com ^^^ http://www.anal-masse-sexfilmer.sexfitte.com ^^^ http://www.sexen-fitte-sug.sexfitte.com ^^^ http://www.monjas-sexis-fetish.sessololiti.com ^^^ http://www.gangbang-rusos-gay.sessololiti.com ^^^ http://www.hardcore-coppia-esibizionista.sesso-loliti.com ^^^ http://www.film-caldi-sesso.sesso-loliti.com ^^^ http://www.analsex-sexll.toyt3.info ^^^ http://www.nitten-barne-sexspill.toyt3.info ^^^ http://www.shy-poliziotto-diteggiatura.tettin3.info ^^^ http://www.insegnanti-fighe-perverse.tettin3.info ^^^ http://www.modelle-brasiliane-gay.tett1ne.info ^^^ http://www.retiring-diavolette-dildo.tett1ne.info ^^^ http://www.lampeggianti.tard0ne.info ^^^ http://www.sexy-poses-anales.tard0ne.info ^^^ http://www.alto-dannazione.t3ttine.info ^^^ http://www.sesso-nude-incinto.t3ttine.info ^^^ http://www.elskelig-student-dritt.t0yt3.info ^^^ http://www.beskjeden-imager.t0yt3.info ^^^ http://www.omasex-jolie-lesbiennes.sl3tterig.info ^^^ http://www.terugtrekkend-blonde-dubbel-penetrerend.sl3tterig.info ^^^

  • Page 1 of 1 pages

Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: