HOME | CONTRIBUTE A STORY! | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES OF INTEREST | CONTACT ME

image

So, Ya Wanna Be a Church Leader, Huh?!

Orginally published on Monday, October 09, 2006 at 4:24 AM
by Todd Rhoades

Eugene Peterson begins his paraphrase of I Timothy 3 in The Message with the words, "If anyone wants to provide leadership in the church, good!" BUT… Huh? I hate that word. Why does there always have to be a ‘but’?…

The writer then gives us some modern day listings of things that Paul says are an absolute must for church leaders today. Peterson calls them "preconditions".

Monday mornings are always a great time for a reality check. As church leaders, we must take the time periodically to measure ourselves against the standard. I'm asking that we all take fifteen minutes this morning to self-evaluate how we're doing. It could make a big difference in your week; and in your ministry.

Take some time right now. Don't just skim this list... read each item individually. Write down some action steps on your weaker points. And thank God when you're doing well in others.

OK... here we go.  A leader must be...

1.  well-thought-of
Are there people in your church right now that you need to clear the air with?  Are there people you are trying to lead who don't think well of you?  How can you make it right this week?

2.  committed to his wife
How close is your relationship?  Sure, you may feel totally committed to your wife, but does she know that?  Do whatever you need to this week to make your spouse feel vibrant and a useful part of your ministry.

3.  cool and collected
Have you blown your temper lately?  Have you held a grudge?  Again... is there someone you're trying to lead who you are ticked at?  Pray for God's help to stay cool and collected even under pressure.

4.  accessible
Is your office door open or closed right now?  Are you accessible to your staff?  to your church?  to other pastors in your community?  to those who oppose you?

5.  hospitable
Are you friendly?  Do people feel comfortable around you?  How long has it been since you've opened your home to new people?

6.  he must know what he's talking about
Are you well-researched?  Do you really know what you're talking about, or do you do a good job 'snowing' people?

7.  not be overfond of wine
Is this a temptation of yours?  If so, watch out.

8.  not pushy but gentle
Are you a leader or a manipulator?  Are you motivational or abusive?

9.  not thin-skinned
Are you sitting around this morning consumed by bad comments from yesterday?  Think about the positive things that were accomplished yesterday.  Truth be told, many more people were ministered to in a postive way than were upset about something that went wrong.

10.  not money-hungry
Are you consumed and motivated by money? 

11.  handle his own affairs well
What personal affairs are in shambles?  Take some time to do your best to get your personal affairs in good shape today so you can concentrate on ministry.

12.  attentive to his own children and having their respect
Don't place your ministry over family.  Spend some time with your kids today.  Quality and Quanity.

13.  must not be a new believer
Not much you can do here... hopefully you can check this one off your list!  smile

14.  outsiders must think well of him
What does your community think about you?  Who cares, you ask?  Evidently, it's important... because Paul stuck it in here.  Make a list of things you could do to help people in your community have a good impression of you!

There you have it... how did you do?

FOR DISCUSSION:  Was there a certain area that God really spoke to you in?  What are you struggling with?  What are you doing well with?  (Feel free to post anonymously if need be).  How important is it to follow these guidelines in your own ministry?


This post has been viewed 3177 times so far.


 TRACKBACKS: (0) There are 38 Comments:

  • Posted by

    WOW! I did way better than I thought I would! Funny thing is, when I worked in the secular world, I tended to have GREAT struggles with my temper. Since working in the ministry, I haven’t struggled with it so much, even though the stresses seem to be, on certain occasions, far greater. I’ve got a couple areas to work on better… Thanks for the list!

  • Posted by

    I am a single church leader.  Although I desire to be married one day to the woman God has for me, I am constantly challenged on my singleness because I am now 40 years old.  I sometimes think I should leave full time ministry because I am not married.  But I know that is the wrong approach.  Isn’t it better to be single?  Of course I know Paul says it’s better to be married than burn in your lust.  I’m not burning in my lust, in fact, after being burned by 2 previous engagements, I’m a bit gun shy and often suspect of women who approach me in the church.  Any comments?

  • Posted by

    Peter D . 

    Paul Was single and Chose to be that way because it gave hiim time to spend on his ministry

  • Posted by Leonard

    Great post.  The great part of that list is when it is not a list but a life style, our whole life is better.  We experinces more joy, impact for God’s Kingdom and the lives of those around us is richer too.  It is a win/win situation for pastors and leaders.  God bless and have a great week!

  • Posted by

    Peter D.

    Don’t sweat it. There are a lot of reasons to stay single, and doing ministry better is a good one. Although the norm in the ancient world was marriage, hence the instruction cited, many chose to serve God un-married. It continues today.

  • Posted by

    Peter D. 

    Just think if we could follow Pauls Ministry to the T How different would our leadership be in our churches today I was married at 42 and I found a big difference in my love of GOD and fellow man.

  • Posted by

    I am a pastor but do not have a wife.  I do however have a husband of 30 years.  Do I still qualify as a good leader?

  • Posted by

    I would like to comment on being accessable. Probably the one of the greatest difficulties I have in the city is with pastors who make people wait weeks before they can see them. When there is crisis people need help now not days or weeks from now. My policy is that every contact from a person who is hurting is an important one and needs our attention as soon as possible.  I was amazed that over the 51 years I have been in ministry in New York that all of the issues on the list are in order in my personal life and work. It’s to bad all of this happens through maturity and experience and isn’t always as evident when you were young.  Thanks for the good word. Gene always as something good to say in a practical way. Sincerely, Chuck Rigby

  • Posted by

    Margaret,

    I think if you are faithful to God and your husband and have no excessive problems in your church and follow your life under God’s law then you are a good leader!!!!

  • Posted by

    Margaret,
    My mother was a minister.  Although some denominations would have you believe that women should not be pastors, I strongly disagree with them.  Since you’re faithful to your family, God will be faithful to your leadership.  Pastors who put the church ahead of their family often fail, as they should, their priorities are wrong.

  • Posted by Linda

    These are great posts!  One thing I believe a leader should be is faithful (must be at church—not stay home over every little headache), and must be a tither. You guys may laugh at me saying that and think those things are just a “given” but you’d be surprised at how many people who say they are committed lack faithfulness and responsibilty and tithing.

  • Posted by Ken Unger

    Mr. Rhoades, Have you ever pastored a church? Your messages often seem to me to lay an unrealistic burden on pastors - one almost too grievous to be born. I used to do that to pastors before I became one. After being in pastoral ministry for 23 years - actually after doing so for one year - I was much more gracious than you seem to be. I was just curious to know if you had ever pastored. You see, I somehow suspect Paul himself would have had a real problem living up to these requirements. Both he and Jesus were more interested in being the salt of the earth than its sugar. 

    Best wishes,

    Ken R. Unger

    *****Response from Todd
    Ken,

    No, I’ve never been a senior pastor.  I was, however a worship pastor for nearly 18 years, and have served with and worked with a good number of senior pastors in my day.  I’m not sure what comments I made that you feel were ungracious.  These requirements/this list are not of my own concoction, Ken… they come straight from the NT as admonitions to Timothy.  If you feel my comments about the list were ungracious, then so be it.  I can’t take any credit for the ungracefulness of the list itself though… you’ll have to take that up with someone else.  smile

    Todd

  • Posted by

    Linda, while I agree tithing is a good thing, I believe it goes beyond that.  The New Testament model of giving is not tithing though, it means that everything you have is God’s, and you must be willing to give it all up.  God requires 100% of your time, your talent and your treasure.  That doesn’t mean we give everything away, but it does mean we must be prepared to.

  • Posted by

    I knew you would’nt post my comment. This blog is so “nice” it makes Jesus sick. You have become nicer than God !!! We are supposed to be at war with anti-christ spirit, and it seems that you are the one to surrender. If you think my post hurts feelings, you would try to kill John the Baptist.

    *********RESPONSE FROM TODD
    Dalton,

    Brother… I know not of what you speak.  (You make no sense).  I haven’t edited any comment from you off this blog.  The attempted murder charge of John the Baptist aside, you make absolutely no sense.

    Todd

  • Posted by Leonard

    Ken Wrote:  You see, I somehow suspect Paul himself would have had a real problem living up to these requirements. Both he and Jesus were more interested in being the salt of the earth than its sugar.

    Ken I am not sure what you mean.  Could you explain in light of the fact Paul wrote these words under the leading of the Holy Spirit.  He wrote these words to a young pastor that was one of his protégé’s.  How is this list more sugar than salt?  I do not want to misunderstand you so could you please help me?  Thanks

  • Posted by

    I think that there are nine items which even if the above fourteen are without fault and are maintaned in the highest degree, number fifteen nullifies all the others...a husband of one wife.  How many leaders who have been choosen by God, are shoved into the closet or the obscure part of the ministry because they are divorced and remarried.  Some times I wonder if that is not the most unpardonable sin!
    In His Service:
    Pastor Bill

  • Posted by

    Pastor Bill,

    I once pointed out to a church I was applying to work with that if you read their bylaws strictly, if one guy is divorced because his wife left him, then he can’t serve in ministry there, but if the same guy MURDERS his wife before she leave him, then is sent to prison, gets out 20 years later… there is no reason he can’t serve.

    Curious…

    Ken Unger, Uh… I think that this was a self-examination based on scripture. If you’re around MMI for any length of time, you know that Todd has indeed served in pastoral ministry and has nothing but the highest regard for those who do.

    Dalton,

    Thanks for your helpful comments in teh conversation…

  • Posted by

    It encourages me when something that I act on somehow later shows up in an article or sermon.  I am (was) a volunteer intern at my church directing the Junior High ministry.  Over the past few months I have noticed a decline in my family’sspiritual growth.  I work a full time job where I am out of the house for twelve hours a day and am trying to build a ministry that I am extremely passionate about in addition to that.  Until recently I had been doing 80% of the work and just barely allowing the other 20% go to others who work along side me.  I tried giving away more of the responsibility in order to give my family the time they deserve but I found other ways to keep busy within the context of ministry.  I say all this to justify the fact that I stepped down from my position in order to fullfil my responsibility to my family first.  I did this with the intention of returning to ministry after I am able to establish boundaries and help restore my family’s walk with Christ.  This decision has not gone over well, but I stand firm no matter the consequences.  It broke my heart having to abandon the kids that I minister to but it has been breaking my heart even worse watching my children’s relationship with God diminish.

  • Posted by

    Thanks for including the comments about women and marriage. As an ordained woman, it is important to realize that husbands need our love and respect too, they are in as difficult a spot as wives. I could not do what I do without my husband’s love and support.

  • Posted by

    Peter D:  Tithing is a must for Christians and especially leaders in today’s church.  It’s a mindset that it all belongs to God and trusting that He will take care of your needs—the law of reciprocity is 100% valid—so valid, in fact, that it is promised throughout both Old & New Testaments.  Of course it goes “beyond that” but we’re just talking here about individual issues here related to leadership.  However I do strongly agree with your comment about putting your family before ministry and women in ministry.

    And Pastor Bill, you are right about pastors being divorced.  My husband is a pastor, was divorced 25 years ago.  His dad told him once that would be an issue for us, but he told his dad “I only have one wife.” He does.

    Oh my gosh, I’m sure that will bring some “Christianese” comments!

    I’m not sure this comment thing is good or not......seems like some folks just want to be contentious.  If I just wanted to argue, I’d call the congregation.  I was thinking this would be a source of encoragement, not opinions and comments from people who feel more powerful if they are correcting their peers.  Geez!

    Todd, I always enjoy your emails and articles.  I think I’ll just stick to that in the future.  The only reason I posted a comment is because our church has been looking into this issue (leadership) and actually looking at material to use in training leadership.  Thanks for all you do.

  • Posted by Ken

    Leonard asked for a clarification of my comments. My experience in pastoring churches tells me that many churches are not interested in following Jesus. Their parishoners are often more interested in being coddled than in being challenged to take up their cross and follow Jesus. Such churches choose pastors who are more “the sugar of the earth” than the salt of the earth. The article this week and many othes from this web site reinforce that impression. It seems many institutional churches are looking for niceness more than newness, religion rather than righteousness. Interestingly, the word nice doesn’t appear anywhere in the Bible, and religion is only positively mentioned once.

    Niceness to me equates with innocuous. It seems many churches would rather have a pastor who works extremely long hours for low pay and never ruffles anyone’s feathers than one who would challenge the congregation to tithe - or in fact be willing to give all they have - to advance God’s kingodm. Most ‘christians’ have never made even one desciple in their entire life, and that’s what we’re here for. They’ve never prayed with someone and seen them healed, they’ve never begun to consider becoming responsibe for relational problems that they cause. Jesus spoke a lot about relational integrity, and he wsn’t just addressing pastors.

    This doesn’t mean that Jesus or Paul were always nice. Jesus made the religious leaders so angry they wanted to kill him. So did Paul, who also got the civic leaders so upset with him they actually tried to kill him. Know any pastors who would do that?

    I just feel that the tenor of articles on this web site are usualy aimed at telling pastors they must be perfect.  It’s no wonder so many clergy burn out, have problems with their families, or just resign from frustration over the huge gap between what the Bible says a Christian is and what their parishoners aspire to be. If you want to truly help pastors, encourage them, don’t just lay more guilt trips on them. God calls imperfect people to leadership. Try offering them more grace than law and see what happens.

  • Posted by matt

    I must kindly disagree with Ken...although I totally agree with the fact that there are many churches that exist soley to make people feel good.  I’m just not sure that has anything to do with the article.

    I think the things that Todd posts are always helpful and challenging and I don’t see a problem with the characteristics listed above.  I think a pastor needs to have all of those things somewhat under control in order to be an effective leader.  The only one I will throw up caution on is Availability.  This can really be an issue in larger churches where the SP can’t afford to meet with everyone who needs to be counseled.  It’s just not practical or wise.  Other pastors in the church must step in to meet these needs.

    Ken, which of the above characteristics do you take issue with?

  • Posted by

    Ken says “Interestingly, the word nice doesn’t appear anywhere in the Bible, and religion is only positively mentioned once.” I think when 1 Cor. 13 says love is patient and kind, that’s kinda saying that love is “nice.”

    I get where you’re coming from though. Yes, as pastors we need to challenge and disciple our people. I agree, but I’m with Matt above, the stuff posted here, and for the most part, the comments, are tremendously helpful for me in my ministry and my life. And they challenge me… grace in my face and all that…

  • Posted by kent

    What is interesting to me is the reactions of people to what is posted. I believe Todd puts them on the site to generate conversations, and engage our thinking. If you disagree, so, fine, you disagree. You agree, cool. For the most part the replies are fun to read. Once in while someone gets up a head of steam and fires off. Okay whatever.

    We all come from different situation and settings. Some are more conservative than I am other are more liberal, whatever that means. ken may have a points but I do not have to agree but he makes me think, makes me remember why I have the point I do. I don’t know what Dalton’s thing is, but there ya go. I enjoy this site because to sparks conversation and makes me think about some of the issues. it is fun.

  • Posted by kent

    So, Ya Wanna Be a Church Leader, Huh?!

    My first reply was - nope, not today. probably tomorrow, but not today.

  • Page 1 of 2 pages

     1 2 >
Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: