Orginally published on Wednesday, November 01, 2006 at 6:01 AM
by Todd Rhoades
On his blog, Ben Arment shares the top ten reason church plants fail from a recent article he read. We have a lot of church planters that read MMI each and every day... take a look and see what you think of this list. I'd love to hear your comments...
1. Lack of a clear definition of “success”
2. Prematurely launching public worship
3. Mismatch between the planter and the community
4. Someone didn’t accurately assess the planter
5. Lack of ongoing training and coaching
6. Putting too much stock in one big event or campaign
7. Taking on too much overhead too soon [eg: office space]
8. The inability or unwillingness to recruit new people
9. Inability to prioritize the right activities and investments
10. Unwillingness to change the strategy when it doesn’t work
What do you think? Have you ever planted a church that ultimately failed? Was it because of one of these ten reason, or something totally different?
This post has been viewed 2444 times so far.
There are 16 Comments:
We had a church plant fail, and the reason were in my opinion were 3,4,5 and 10. I am also sure that we contributed to the failure. I did not speak early enough or loud enough when the plant was crashing. We are now considering we are going to so it again. Ironically it is not the investment that is the catch, it is the partnership we would have. That and we are considering a multi-site option.
Number 2 and 5are huge in the success of a church plant. I planted my last church with the Evangelical Covenant and they do an amazing job of helping planters thrive with their process, assessment and coaching.
Our association had two church plants finally fold this summer. We had a bootcamp to train the planters. We had resources. We had a coach hired for the planters. Two churches were the “mothers” for support and accountability. What killed them was the skyrocketing rent. Both were growing steadily but the economy was faster and the competition for commercial space caused both plants to meet to vote to end.
Leonard,
I am a part of Evangelcial Covenant church and I agree with you for the most part, but even we have failures.
The list of reasons New Church plants fail is almost endless. I find nothing in the list to “fuss” about but I would not necessarily say any one of them is THE reason a Church fails.
Far too many new Church plants are either splits or duplications of what is already available. We like to think we are something new, different or special but in reality how different are we really from the Church down the street? Should we be different?
I have been involved diretly or indirectly in a number of Church plants over the years. Many of them failed. Some of the failure was “operator error.” Sometimes, the reason for failure is not evident. Or perhaps, from God’s perspective it was NOT a failure. How do we judge success? Attendance? Offerings? Buildings? I suspect most of the Churches in the NT would be deemed failures by modern evangelical standards.
Eccles. 8:1
Who is like the wise man and who knows the interpretation of a matter? A man’s wisdom illumines him and causes his stern face to beam.
As someone said above, these are all solid reasons. I think we could add to this list, though. In the end (no pun intended), placing our finger on one (or multiple reasons) for why churches don’t fly is like nailing jello to the proverbial tree. It’s just a hard matter to interpret.
Starting a new church is an exteremly difficult task that requires many factors to be in one’s favor. These 10 are some of them, to be sure. It’s no wonder most churches in this country will remain in 100 level. Many of the practical factors in starting a church cannot be spirutualized away. To be sure, every church planting Pastor has to go into the venture with both eyes wide open to the extreme challenges and be willing to face potential failure.
Mat...I appreciate your comment, but I think your default to the pragmatic is the very thing that causes many churches to fail. I don’t think we have too much “spiritualizing” of things...if anything we’ve de-spiritualized things far too often. I’m working on an article for this very subject and it should be complete within a day or two.
I am planting a church at the beginning of the year. I deeply believe that this is where God is leading me. I do not have the experience as many of you, in planting, but your responses are encouraging and a little scary as well. I ask that you pray for me and my family as we move towards this great task and any advice that you can give I am willing to read it and or listen to your helpful advice.
Sincerely,
Al
Coaching and assesment are your best friends until you plant. If you haven’t taken care of one or both, get it done. Where are you planting, Al?
Rick, thanks for your response. I am planting in the metro Atlanta area. I am just 30 miles south of downtown Atlanta, GA. I have some assesment material from the Southern Baptist Assoc. here in GA, but I haven’t taken any coaching. Where can I find out about coaching?
Al
Al...do you mean that you have material or that you have actually been assessed by an SBC representative with an interview, etc.
As for coaching, you’re in a perfect area. Ed Stetzer is in Cumming and is “the man” on all things regarding church starts. Even if he can’t do it, he should be able to refer you to a decent coach in the metro area. All his pertinent info is on his web site:
http://www.newchurches.com/index.php
Since he’s SBC, you might already be aware and connected to Ed.
Rick, yes, I met with two SBC representatives on two seperate occassions and I was given personal assessment material as well. I will check with Ed Stetzer in Cummings and see what help I can get from him.
Thank you for your assistance and any future help that you may have. What I get from you and others will be beneficial to me when I can help someone else who needs a little or a lot of help along the way.
Al
I am planting in the metro Atlanta area. I am just 30 miles south of downtown Atlanta, GA.
I have some assesment material from the Southern Baptist Assoc. here in GA, but I haven’t taken any coaching. Where can I find out about coaching?
i’ve got the same problem, and i found the solution here to top registry cleaner, just for reference.
Different running shoes serve different wow power leveling purposes. Regardless of their type though, it’s a good idea to buy new running shoes every four to six months if you exercise regularly. Worn-down running shoes will wow gold cause pain and injury to knee joints because of the lack of cushioning needed for each stride. The rule of thumb for replacement is when the treads are worn down to the point where Warhammer Online Power Leveling the original rubber design has faded almost completely. Another good test is to put them on a flat surface Warhammer Online Gold and see if they wobble significantly when you nudge them. If so, they have worn unevenly, and it’s time for a new pair. Keep in WAR Power leveling mind that most running shoes have a life of 350 to 550 miles.kj,jhmgh
Page 1 of 1 pages