I'm not sure what this list is all about... it's from The Church Report Magazine, and it's entitled "Special Report: Christian Movies". Some I can see, others are a stretch. See what you think:
1. Last Holiday
2. X2: X-Men United
3. Lady in the Water
4. Nacho Libre
5. Signs
6. Walk the Line
7. The End of the Spear
8. Chronicles of Narnia
9. Lord of the Rings
10. The Passion
11. Raising Helen
12. Bruce Almighty
13. To End All Wars
14. The Apostle
15. Babette’s Feast
16. The Exorcism of Emily Rose
17. Magnolia
18. A Walk to Remember
19. The Big Kahuna
20. Shadowlands
FOR DISCUSSION: Any of these movies overtly ‘Christian’?
Todd
- - - - - - - - - -
Signs for sure, though it’s essentially an argument for Calvinism… End of the Spear, even though I haven’t seen it… Chronicles of Narnia, of course; the Passion, yes, even though it doesn’t have a Christian ‘message’ (it shows how not cool the crucifixion was, but it doesn’t explain it in the slightest...); Bruce Almighty, of course, and I loved Morgan Freeman as God! The exorcism of Emily Rose featured a priest as a more or less good guy, though I don’t know if that makes it ‘Christian’; a Walk to Remember? yeah, that was a pretty decently Christian movie, although I think it was mostly a touching story with a Christian as the main character.
The trick here is to separate movies about Christianity (or with a Christian message) from movies featuring Christians. The two aren’t necessarily the same.
My two cents.
-Daniel-
It would help to know the context and how they define a Christian movie. Point of view? Characters? Audience Demographic?
Some of these I can’t comment on because I’ve not seen them. Stuff like “Narnia” and “Lord of the Rings” are givens. “The Apostle” is a tremendous film and I highly recommend it. Great presentation of a flawed man who seeks redemption, grace, and forgiveness, plus it is a neat examination of the evangelical culture. Not sure why “Nacho Libre” is on here, but I haven’t seen it. “Signs” beyond a shadow of doubt belongs on the list, as does “Bruce Almighty.” “Walk the Line” was outstanding. It suffered, though, in my opinion, from not exploring Cash’s redemption more explicitly. I may be wrong, but he had a pretty strong conversion experience.
One GLARING omission for me would be “The Green Mile.” If you haven’t seen it, be warned. It is rated R and deservedly so. It takes place on Death Row in Louisiana during the Depression. The execution scenes are gruesome and one in particular is downright horriffic. But the message of the movie and the symbolism is undeniable.
I could go on and on....having a Master’s in Theater, I’m passionate about films, tv, theater, etc. and the impact they can have on Kingdom work. Thanks for sharing the list, Todd.
Bruce Almighty was rather blasphemous, and I’m not a prude. Wlk the line was an okay movie, but I don’t think it really covered Johnny Cash’s later conversion and stronger beliefs in Jesus.
It was just June’s determination to straighten Him out. Signs had that underlying theme of finding your faith again, and that God is at work though we may not understand His ways. I can’t cooment on too many others.
I know plenty of churches where Bruce Almighty would be seen as accurate theology! None that I would attend, but they are out there.
I didn’t waste any time or $ on the others except for Shadowlands… which had a very searching for God theme.
It’s been a while since I’ve seen X2, but I can’t remember anything about it that would put it on this list. Did I miss something?
Why would LOTR be on here? Yes, it’s by a Christian, but Tolkein claimed it was just a story, not an allegory.
The way some of these seem to have been selected, they may as well have put War of the Worlds on the list also, since Morgan Freeman’s lines at the beginning and end imply that God was involved.
By the way, where is “Chariots of Fire”? It’s not one of my favorties, but it’s certainly worthy of a list like this.
A few I would have used instead:
“Simon Birch” would be way up there. “A Perfect Stranger” was made to be a Christian message movie, based on the book “Dinner With a perfect Stranger”.
Some of their list don’t seem like movies I would qualify as “Christian”, any more than I would consider Woody Allen’s “Bananas” a Jewish movie.
Dude, how could they possibly leave out Left Behind. With such great acting and production...it has to be at the top of the list!
Bobby, lol… And how about “The Omega Code”?
I’m a HUGE movie buff, I can speak to what I think put some of these on the list.
2. X2: X-Men United (shows Christ-like self sacrifice - also, producer Ralph Winter is a believer)
5. Signs (shows a man returning to faith after understanding how God works things together for good. Pretty sure Shyamalan is not a believer, though...)
6. Walk the Line (Cash was a Christian, and his faith is briefly alluded to and displayed)
7. The End of the Spear (obviously a film made by Christians for Christians)
8. Chronicles of Narnia (also obvious)
9. Lord of the Rings (obvious to me, not to everyone. Tolkien’s worldview was very Christian, and his story, I feel, can’t be understood apart from that, and was very well translated to the screen.)
10. The Passion (Sorry, I DO think this was a Christian film, and I do think Mel is a real believer...)
12. Bruce Almighty (Director is a believer, view of God is pretty accurate I think.)
14. The Apostle (Robert Duvall is admittedly not a Christian, but the film has value nonetheless)
15. Babette’s Feast (BEAUTIFUL story of self-sacrifice, one of the all-time greats. Rent it today.)
16. The Exorcism of Emily Rose (I thought it was a reasonably accurate depiction of how evil and hell behave. I understand believers were involved in either directing, producing or writing)
18. A Walk to Remember (I’m not sure it was produced, written, or directed by a believer, but it has some awesome Switchfoot music. Isn’t that enough?)
20. Shadowlands (There’s two of these, btw, one that was made for the BBC which shows C.S.Lewis’ faith pretty well, and the movie with Anthony Hopkins which buries it.)
Raising Helen is the story of an irresponsible woman raising her sister’s kids after the sister dies. Kate Hudson is the main character, and she meets and falls in love with the minister who leads the Lutheran(?) school the kids attend. I think he’s Lutheran. Maybe Methodist. I don’t remember, he could be a snake-handler for all I know. Anyway, he’s protrayed in very positive light. Charming, funny, and compassionate. Cute movie, but not worthy of the list. Although, like Todd, I’m not sure what the list is really about.
Well, it is obvious from these comments that what is sorely needed is a definitive explanation of what, exactly, makes a movie “Christian.” I am so happy to help. I posted a response over at the View From Her that really just simplifies the whole thing.
Where’s Pay it Forward and Angel and the Badman ? Those are two of my favorite movies of all time and in my opinion have Christian themes.
From a review by christiananswers.net - If Pay It Forward does not challenge Christians to be salt and light in a depraved world, then my suggestion is for those of apathy to reflect deep inside to see if Christ has really changed their heart. To be a Christian who follows the example of Jesus we must be living costly lives, surrendered to Christ and fighting off the lure of ease and comfort. If Trevor, a poor pre-teen with no Christian background, can see the impact he can make for the better, what more should we be doing to reach the lost? Jesus Christ already paid the ultimate price two thousand years ago. He ‘paid it forward’, and now we are indebted to serving him in our lives if we truly love Him.
Angel and the Badman features John Wayne in one of his best roles as a notorious gunfighter. When he is wounded in a shootout, a pacifist Christian/Quaker family takes him in and nurses him back to health. While in their care, he falls in love with the daughter, who begs him to change his ways. At the end Wayne shows he is willing to give up the violent life he has always known for her.
What happened to Because of Winn-Dixie?
I can’t believe “Braveheart” isn’t on the list, but I do give them major kudos for including “Babbette’s Feast.”
I see I’m going to have to visit the video store to check out a few of these.
Since Shadowlands and Narnia were listed, I thought I’d mention a cool little Lewis flick I saw recently. It’s called “Beyond Narnia” (I think) and it has an actor portray Lewis telling his life story. It’s filmed at Oxford and The Kilns and almost the entire script is taken verbatim from Lewis’ work, primarily “Surprised by Joy” and “A Grief Observed.” I thought it was very well done. Stumbled across it at the local Hollywood Video.
I had big issues with “Pay It Forward” which as I recall, had someone buy a bottle of booze for an alcoholic. That was presented as a positive, as was the hospital ER scene where a man pulled a gun to get what he wanted. Negatives portrayed as positives outweigh any good qualities the movie may have had. Then again it’s been a while since I saw it, but I do remember my reaction at the time.
Dave
Chariots of Fire needs to be on the list. Eric Liddell’s faith-based stand is one that non-believers as well as believers can respect.
Not only is Chariots of Fire a clearly Christian movie, the heading is TOP 20 Christian movies, which may be speaking of the artistic quality. COF won an Academy Award for Best Picture, so how many Christian flicks get that kind of recognition? To leave it off this list is a glaring error.
Page 1 of 1 pages