Orginally published on Monday, November 15, 2004 at 9:10 AM
by Todd Rhoades
Last week, I came across a blog entry at "Nameless Youth Pastors"… take a quick read (this is how it was written… so please excuse all the typos and small caps!): watz next? i don’t know where to start. i’v considered leaving uth min all together & i still want to jump back in… i’m tired. tired of resumes. tired of churches not knowing themselves. tired of my own failures. tired of pastors being pawns of powerful people. tired of praying 4 guidance. tired of waiting. tired of crying.
i don't cry. typical emotionally constipated male and all that. i've been visiting the big-church-down-the-street <doesn't every town have a big-church-down-the-street?> & the last 3 times i was there, i cried during the sermon. he's a good preacher but it's been more than that. it's been refreshing to hear from God even when i'm confused and even angry w/ God.
in case u missed it, i'm tired & trying 2 hold on
Have you ever been there? "Nameless Youth Pastor" transparently writes how each of us probably feels at least once during ministry. Some of you are there now. Others have just come through a time of questioning what's next... questioning your calling... questioning God. Emotions run high. If answers could just be black and white.
But many times they aren't. David Hansen writes in his book "The Art of Pastoring: Ministry Without All the Answers": Sometimes my head gets filled with static. My problems are shouting, flaunting themselves above my faith. Self-pity orders my emotions around like a sergeant. My talents scatter before the cacophonous taunts of the enemy: depression. Years ago I forced myself to work through these times. Eventually I learned that when these feelings come, I must stop trying to work, stop listening to the noise in my head and start paying attention to God. What I inevitably find when I pay attention to God during these times is that he is there, ready to listen. I need to drop everything and pray.
Knowing what's next is never easy. And many times, it's not until you finally make the next step that everything finally makes sense. (And sometimes it NEVER makes sense!)
Let's share some of our stories... Have you ever felt like the "Nameless Youth Pastor"? What did you do next? What advice would you have for others who are going through this process? As we support one another we provide a valuable service to those "nameless youth pastors" out there who are just searching and wanting to do God's will...
This post has been viewed 754 times so far.
TRACKBACKS: (0)
There are 63 Comments:
I can relate with the nameless youth pastor today. I know God has called me, He has confirmed it several times, but I can’t seem to find a place to serve. At times it gets very frustrating and exhausting. When I am down and discouraged, I stop and pray. It does not always help the discouragement, but I give to the Father any way. He will make all things clear in His time not mine.
Seems like some blog-convergence happening here. Manipulators. Courage. Time to Leave.
The sermon I have yet to preach: “I’m Tired of Being Driven,” whether it’s purpose, prayer, worship, disciplines, ... ad nauseum.
At least this guy knows when to stop.That’s more than most of us!
He starts with honesty and self-awareness. That’s better than most of us!
The shock at the lack of respondents by the first “Manipulator” respondent is rather suggestive. Every church/ministry/mission has them. Maybe we are just to tired to confront them.
To tired for Courage? I can’t help but wonder if courage isn’t easier when you have “back-up” resources (royalties, or a spouse with full-time employment… for me it was the latter). Trusting God is easier talked than walked.
I think he is right. It is about calling. And not just for youth pastors. Lamenting prophets are not alone.
But, what do I know. It’s Monday morning.
I feel for the nameless youth pastor, I have been there. I would suggest first and foremost get with your accountability partner, what you don’t have one? There in is your problem. Frustration in the ministry is going to happen. Someone doesn’t pray to recieve Christ, a sheep passes away, a sheep bits you, a sheep won’t follow, the list goes on. I have found that having someone to talk to who knows my heart for God and Ministry is essential to my survival. I know you spiritual guys are enjoying this, you probably are pointing folks back to the Bible. You forget that the Bible for many of us is our life, but sometimes we need flesh to help us see the truths of the Bible. Please don’t discount the value of a brother in Christ who cares deeply for your ministry. The unfortunate thing is that most of those who quit ministry never allow someone into there life to help them. We think we can go it alone. How do I know? Just last week a local youth pastor took his life. I reached out to him on many occassions,his reply, “I’ll get back to you.” He never did, I only wished I could have done more! The truth is he wouldn’t let me. Read Hebrews 10:25, it encourages us to never leave the fellowship alone, even as the day grows darker. This past week, my daughter and I watched The Lord of the Rings, The King Returns. In the middle of the movie I was reminded how our world is slowly moving toward the return of our Lord. Mordolf (spelling?) was looking out over the plan with one of the little people. The little person asked if the end was near. I paraphrase the comment, “the end is only the beginning!” My friend you and I are living in dark days! The end is near, as it nears the importance of uniting with brothers and sisters in Christ is paramount to survival. In Ephesians 6 Paul encourages us to put on the armor of God so that we might stand, you will not find anywhere that we are told to fight, but only to stand. It then tells of the pieces of the armor, the belt of truth, the breast plate, the boots, the helmet, the sword, and the sheild of faith. The sheilds in those days were made to lock together enabling an army to form an impenatrible sheild. There in is the secret to survival, brothers locking our hearts together in Christ, protecting one another from the enemy. May God bless you and all those who are considering today as their last day of minstry. Don’t give up, Don’t give in, Don’t quit! Someone is praying for you today.
I am in exactly the same spot - and sick of it all! I left my last church 9 months ago (along with the entire staff, except the pastor, all on the same day), and I have had countless interviews, sent countless resumes, answered countless questionaires. I have been in the “top 5” or “top 3” only to never get the job countless times. I don’t know what to do or what’s next. Thankfully I have found a way to make a living during this time. It’s not much, but it pays the bills. It’s only money, though. Not what I’m supposed to be doing. So here I am - after 13 years of great student ministry, sitting in my house all day selling on ebay, planning my next move to diabolically take over the entire earth. And trying to figure out how to pay the student loan and the mortgage. At least I still have my great physique and sense of humor.
Wow, do I relate to this email. Currently, I am searching out what God has called me to in ministry. At times I feel He desires me to be a pastor, other times I feel He desires me to be a teacher. Sometimes I just do not feel anything. Always searching and discussing with my wife can really get you down not just on yourself, but your wife, life in general, etc. The call is real, that I know, it is just the implementation of the call that is so unknown at this time.
Give in one day and one day only! After the one day of retreat. Return to duty.God’s Grace is sufficient. You will not go under during that one day of retreat. You will become stronger and energized.
I am currently undergoing the second extended period of unemployment in a 21 yr ministry career. I am just 2 mths short of the 18 mths I endured 15 yrs ago. I am just as penniless now, as I was then, but much more indebted now than I was then. I smile when I read George Barna’s recent poll that suggests that most persons in the marketplace for a pastorate would not choose a small church, because the majority of my 200+ applications have been to small churches. The negative or non-responses have been just short of alarming. What is worse, is the apathy and indifference of my ministy colleagues, especially those of my denomination and my own city: it is a rude and brutal awakening. Ministry colleagues are perhaps, the worst candidates for giving encouragement to a pastoral soul in difficult times.
Nameless Youth Pastor, all will be well. WAITING on God is no big deal. The frustrations of waiting would not cause most of uscommit apostasy or suicide, anyway! What I have learned, though, is that it is the QUALITY of waiting that matters: shall we wait in agitation and seething anger at God, or shall we wait in QUIETNESS and JOY? I have tried both, and have decided that the latter is BETTER. I have no idea when my “night” shall end, and, frankly, there is a sense in which I care not whether it is sooner or later, but I know that when it ends, all will still be well with me, and I shall be place JUST where He who has called me wants me. YES, at the heart of this is the CALL - the call, formulated before we were formed in our mothers’ wombs.
It is in times like this that we learn the PRACTICE of faith, which goes beyond the mere PRONOUNCEMENT of faith. All will be well, Nameless Youth Pastor! All IS well!
There are hundreds, likely thousands sitting in the similar seat. I left a church a year ago because it was an unhealthy staff environment ... only to be followed by the Sr. Pastor. I am also in the process of searching ... I have been turned down but also turned down opportunities, only because we’re not interested in “doing church”. In our journeys to find a church, we have seen many that are a disgrace to God and should have closed the doors because they are “doing conscience-satisfying church” ... and the pastor is there to ensure the safety net of a regular pay check. The philosophy here is ... “no church is better than bad church” but I add ... that is still no excuse for not intentionally finding some kind of a healthy community of believers. The concept of going down the street to the “big church” (or even little) is fine ... but sometimes (not always) it seems so much healthier because it is from the seat of the pew instead of the seat at the leadership and/or board. I was inspired just this week by the story of Rachel Scott told by her father (the girl shot at Columbine). It brings it all back to the surface ... the basics ... her simple philosophy of loving and caring for another and that starts a chain reaction. She had bottom-line intentions of making a difference at whatever cost ... she clearly indicated that her whole life in her diary and life-style and words. Oh to have lived even 5 of her 17 years. Push all the “church” crap to the side ... overlook the “people” crap ... and embrace the examples of Jesus Christ. That’s what I need to do.
Faith in the one calling is the issue I have had to deal with most. Do I really trust Him who has called me to serve His Bride? It is not about me...It is not about you...It is not about us...It is about the One worthy of the calling! I am the first to admit I am unable to fulfill the call placed on my life. Yet, the Father has proven to me over and over, if I will step out of the boat, He will give me water walking lessons. I must first get out of the boat! My Boat! It is hard to suck up the pride and the arrogance and the piety and step out there with only the Father supporting you. It can be done. It is being done. It is time that more fully devoted followers step out of their boat and everyone else’s boat and walk with Jesus with bold faith that is scary and tests every fiber of your being and marriage and relationships and ministry and philosophy and ... The church today is in desperate need of many of you who feel tired and worn to step up to the edge of the boat and show the way out of the boat into the freedom “in Christ” Many of you who read these are right where God wants you to be to change your world...trust and obey...obedience is better than sacrifice...He has called you...HE has called on you...I’VE GOT YOUR BACK...GO AHEAD JUMP OUT THERE...THE VIEW FROM HERE IS AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!
As I read the article this morning I too was struck by how my life corresponds to the youth pastor.
I too left a church begin pressured to conform. It made my heart cry for all who are living in a very disappointing vocation.
However there is hope for the modern church. My family stumbled into such a church recently. It is poor. It is weak. But it has committed itself to reaching our community. We joined and are inviting others into the flock. I haven’t received a position or any employment that can support life, but I see God at work around me.
There are healthy churches. And there are churches that pulled away from the brink of extinction.
As a pastor I have found myself at times wandering around in the wildnerness of too much informational demands as well as suggestions on “how to do” ministry. The stress of it all almost become too much. However I know that the wilderness can be a beneficial surrounding as God works best in the solitude of times ... at least for me. In the pressures of life and ministry a person can become displaced in “hearing” the voice of God. As a minister I was “handling” God’s Word, but I had come to a point of not “hearing” the Word of God. There is a big difference. At times I sense I am in the famine Amos spoke of ... a famine of hearing the words of the Lord (Amos 8:11). I am striving to adapt my times with God in how I read the Word, where I read the Word, and even why I read the Word. It helps me in the dryness of my own wilderness walk. I see more and more that those in ministry are struggling. I want to think this is not the way God would have it to be for us ... but then again there is so much superficial pretense in the ministry today to be “successful” ... maybe the down and out wilderness walks are the mode to which God can gain our attention. A great read (older book) is “Liberating Ministry from the Success Syndrone.” (Kent Huges ... I think). Let us be encouraged to grab the Word and cry out as the Psalmist does in 61, “When my heart is overwhelmed; lead me to the rock that is higher than I.” (vs.2b)
All of you, just resign your ministry, go home, get on your knees, pray, and go out and get a real job. The ministry was never meant to be a full-time family-supporting job. You get caught up in ridiculous things like “how good is my praise band compared to ...” and “what kind of windows would Jesus want in the new sanctuary” and so on. I was once at a church where they actually employed some one whose job it was to hire and fire. I’ve seen five-page employee evaluations. This is insane. Jesus was a penniless beggar who had nothing but the deepest contempt for religious “leaders”. If you really want to make a difference, quit preaching to the choir. Reach out to people on the job, on the streets, and don’t let your left hand know what your right hand is doing. When it’s all said and done, the way you lived your day-to-day life is what you’ll be judged on (Matthew 25).
I stepped out of youth ministry recently. I left a “big church down the street” to start a church because of all of the same things that are being posted. The pastor that I work with is a man of real faith. I am the assoc pastor and I work with college students. It is a very exciting ministry to be a part of and I know that I will be the pastor in a year or so. The refreshing thing about it is that without a doubt, the congregation is FREE! They are free from the power struggles, free from the political garbage and that makes for a spirit filled experience. When I walked away from my ministry with teens, I left the only salary my wife and I had, I walked away from the medical insurance and all the stability that the established congregation brought. I beleive there is more to church than family centered control freak mentalities and the awesome thing is that God has blessed us more than I ever imagined. I do work another job, and that can be difficult to keep up with all the responsibilities of a new church, but God is faithful. My wife and I are living in a brand new home, we are financially blessed and on top of it I am at a church that I love and my staffmates are all people that I love and that are amazingly gifted. Our youth pastor was my intern for a couple of years with my other church and our worship leader was the youth worship leader at my former church and We are so close, because of the whole experience.
I guess what I am saying to my youth ministry compadres out there that are struggling, remember the words that God spoke to Joshua-"Be strong and courageous...Be very strong and courageous.” Maybe a church plant is not the thing for you and the ministry God has for you, but don’t forget the God that called into this thing is the same one that parted the sea, rained down manna, healed the blind, and brought back the dead, He will deliver you.
Justin Hill
WOW! This article hits me exactly where I am. I am brand new to the ministry. I graduated in December of 02 with a MA in Christian Ed. Looked for a job in Children’s Ministry for 18 months finally landing one in May of 04. It was part time and I loved every minute of it. I was finally doing what God had equipped me to do. Then the shocker....I was laid off. This has been my only ministry position and the ones I have applied to since don’t want me because I don’t have enough experience. Where do I get it then? I have 3 internships and one part time position under my belt that’s it. I am really frustrated and seriously considering leaving ministry all together. If no one will hire me what is the point in staying around in a career that no one wants me? I want to know what’s next..should I bail out while I am ahead?
Erik, thanks for your unconvincing, irratational and absolutely ignorant observation.
Are you married? If you are, get a divorce because just as Jesus was penniless he was also single.
Do you own a home? If you do, sell it or better yet give it away and live off of what you can get from others because Jesus didn’t own a home, have children, own a car or even in the slightest bit say we shouldn’t. So when you start spouting off about what you obviously know nothing about you confirm in others what they may have thought about you to begin with.
I understand what pastors go through since I am one. I went from pastoring a church with enormous growth in all areas (average growth in one year went from 211 to 265 and was climbing) but because there was a group of people didn’t like the fact that they didn’t know everyone anymore, then that was all they could take and I lost my job. I was making $57,000 per year and now I’m making $20,000 per year and working 4 different jobs trying to make ends meet. I’ve put in over 200 applications/resumes and Walmart won’t even hire me. I’ve got 4 kids and a wife that I’m tired of watching go to bed night after night crying because we don’t have enough to make it and chuches won’t respond to even say they received my resume.
Today I’m filing for bankruptcy and it’s a great day indeed.
I too have felt the sting of being sidelined. I am a veteran youth minister of almost 18 years and have been blessed beyond measure to have served in an absolutly outstanding youth ministry. Unfortunantly, like many of you, I have been waithing for God’s relocation for almost three years now. Likewise I have gone through the gambit of emmotions just like many of you. One saving grace for me has been a good friend and local youth minister who has recognized my worth, not for my job skills, but for the human-being that I am. He knows my heart and my love for kids. Thank the Lord for sending him because I was quiting forever tired of the powerful and hateful! I’ve said all that to say this. Remenber that God said that he would never give you more than you could bare. Paul said in Phillippians “to press on.” Stay dilligent in the word and the cause. There is alot of minisrtry that still needs to be done out side of the four walls. Actually most all the ministry is outside the four corners. So take courage and open your eyes wide and look aroud. The works still there we just have to get busy and “get er done.” By the way my physique is not what it used to be.
For many of us who have been hurt in ministry or by ministry, these waiting times can be tremendous healing times. If they can become that for us, we will be much stronger and more able to minister when we find a new place of ministry. I encourage you to find a healthy church and allow God to built health into you. Submit yourself to a caring pastor. Do whatever your hand finds to do in the church but do it with humility and grace. Work at whatever you can find to do to support your family. God’s call will not go away and when the time is right, he knows where you are and knows how to get your attention. Make the most of this time to prepare yourself for what God has ahead.
It is hard and having people quote verses to us doesn’t really help. It’s really interesting that the Holy Spirit is the one who is called alongside of us to help carry our load. More often, those of us who are not in your situation use strong words rather than comforting ones. Even though it may take some time and you may be disappointed by some of the people you approach to come alongside of you, keep looking until you find someone because it will make the journey easier. My heart goes out to you and I will pray for all of you that God will encourage your hearts today and in the days ahead.
Been there, done that. It’s so sad that churches often burn out ministers who would otherwise have a very fruitful ministry. And, having been there, it’s also unfortunate that so many ministers approach church problems on our own power---and get spanked.
To Erik:
Got some unresolved issues, have you?
>>>All of you, just resign your ministry, go home, get on your knees, pray, and go out and get a real job. The ministry was never meant to be a full-time family-supporting job.
Wow, really? Do you think that will help the American church actually become more responsible about doing ministry rather than leaving it to the “professional Christians?”
>>>>You get caught up in ridiculous things like “how good is my praise band compared to ...” and “what kind of windows would Jesus want in the new sanctuary” and so on. I was once at a church where they actually employed some one whose job it was to hire and fire. I’ve seen five-page employee evaluations. This is insane.
Now I couldn’t agree with you more here. The American church is run more like a corporation than a ministry (in many churches), and this is indeed unfortunate (and unbiblical).
>>>Jesus was a penniless beggar who had nothing but the deepest contempt for religious “leaders”.
A) Jesus was not a beggar.
B) Religious leaders of His day aren’t the same as those today (well, at least a lot of them aren’t.)
>>>If you really want to make a difference, quit preaching to the choir. Reach out to people on the job, on the streets, and don’t let your left hand know what your right hand is doing. When it’s all said and done, the way you lived your day-to-day life is what you’ll be judged on (Matthew 25).
True. But then, isn’t that what vocational ministers do?
My heart goes out to you in your situation. I myself am a minister who have dealt with displacement in the body. I think many of us have had the experience of where do I fit or belong to be used of God. I guess the best way to look at it is, did I do what was pleasing to God while I was there? Is there anything that I disagreed with that I can pray about to bring healing to self as well as release in your own spirit to self. I found that in leaving places that I really wanted to be there was a sense of loss and sometimes regret but I found that other places that I was led to was the doings of God. His ways are past finding out and as we “breathe” and let God take the reins of our lives that the expected end he has prepared will come to pass. There is a good book by Bro. Carothers from prison to praise. Sometimes the places we are in life can feel like a prison, I know, I’m facing one now. Have fought many battles in this place, many I would rather not face yet I know that I cannot orchestrate my life that will please God, so I decided to stop trying and to let God be God. What I ask for now is grace to rest in what God is doing because the next step belive me I cannot make come to pass. Ministry is my passion. It motivates me to sow into others simply because of the depth of love that God has imparted to me. Whether for now that is one on one or to thousands, I’ll let God decide, in the meantime, I’ll take advantage of the opportunities that I encounter daily to sow, and let the gift I sow be measured by God. I hope this helps stay encouraged and remember someone else understands your situation and pray for them too.
Love ya
Sis in Christ.
Its interesting too see the comments about hardships in the ministry. I am not so young as most of you and I have only been in the ministry a short while. I have had experience with basically only one church which I like because I do get to do some of the things I enjoy. Mine is not a paid position but it is rewarding. I conduct an early Sunday morning worship service thru our homeless ministry, and also volunteer two days a week with a clothing ministry. My husband has to carry the financial load alone and it does get tough at times. We don’t have a lot of extras but we do manage to get by. I have sent out dozens of resumes and have yet to get even a response that the resume was received. I have just come to the conclusion that GOD has me where HE wants me. Totally dependent upon HIM. I know that HE knows what is best as HE knows what the outcome will be. I pray a lot because that is all I know to do. HE has not failed us yet.
It is sad to hear of so many called by God who are wandering through the wilderness - trying to find that place where God wants them to serve Him (including myself). My experience of being detached from the Body has reminded me of this - God can use you in other places. Look around and you will find plenty of people in need of the love of Jesus - and you can minister to them without a church title or position. When you’ve mailed so many resumes that you’ve lost count and no one offers you a job - church or secular - don’t give up. Ask God to give you His joy so you can praise Him even in your valley (like Paul & Silas in jail). I was watching a Christian program on TV Saturday night. A man was in a wheelchair with a muscle disorder = muscle turns to bone (don’t remember medical term). I watched this man stand on a cane and sing I Can Only Imagine. This picture remains in my mind’s eye to remind me to be thankful - no matter what. May the peace of Christ be with you.
Unfortunately, not only is this a situation that is very prevalent in ministry, it is a vicious cycle. It seems to go like this: Bad situation- desperate to find something new- quick to move on to next bad situation. It seems like (easier said than done)that we need to be better about interviewing the church as much as they are interviewing us. I liken it to marriage. If we go into the marriage relationship thinking we’re going to change our spouse, then we’re in for a rude awakening. If you dig deep enough, and are truly honest with yourself, the situations you are currently in were waiting for you. The signs were probably there- you were just so desperate to get out of one bad situation that you didn’t do your homework or wanted to believe that you could change the new situation. There is no perfect situation this side of heaven, but God does have a perfect fit for each one of us. We just have to be better at discerning good from best. Like I said, easier said than done…
It’s really depressing to me that there are so many of “us” out there that can identify whether from the past or the present. This is the third time I’ve had extended periods of being out of the pastoral ministry. And yes I’ve even questioned my call, several times and came to the conclusion that this is the only thing that makes me feel fulfilled. It’s also the only thing that creates this kind of pain--strange--or is it? It’s hard to live out all the truths you’ve preached when you’re in the middle of the fire, but I guess it’s God’s way of validating those truths to our lives. I want to thank Job, but then I want to strangle Job, but ultimately I thank God for Job. For I know that God’s promise to Job is also my promise and then some. God help all of us, for He is the only one that can and will… But, no matter how truthful these things are, it doesn’t help the pain, fear, doubt, and discouragement of now.
Sean
Justin:
It amazes me that churches put “5, 10, or whatever years experience a must.” I think many churches are missing out on very gifted ministers because they are focusing on degrees and years of experience. I have a young man in my church who has no degree and little experience, but loves people and has a passion to lead others to Christ. I wouldn’t trade him for anyone. Interviewing for church positions can be very frustrating I know. They never have a conversation with you, never meet you face to face, and yet God still tells them you are not the one??? It is sad to say, but I found that when I was interviewing for church positions it was not much different than corporate America...it is who you know. With that being said, I am happy to say that God was always in control and lead me to the church He wanted me to serve. Don’t allow search committees and deacon boards to discourage you or throw you off course. Most of them have good intentions, but they have no more of a clue how to choose a pastor than I do how to choose a mechanic. I figure since he has the Mr. Goodwrench sign on the wall and a certification he must know how to fix my car...boy have I been wrong a few times.
Page 1 of 3 pages
1 2 3 >