HOME | CONTRIBUTE A STORY! | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES OF INTEREST | CONTACT ME

Why Do Pastors Leave the Ministry?

Orginally published on Tuesday, May 30, 2006 at 10:00 AM
by Todd Rhoades

WaveScott Williams is a pastor who is no longer pastoring.  Recently on his blog, he wrote an essay on leaving the ministry… below is a sampling of what he wrote…

“many people have asked me why i am stepping out of pastoring, at least for a while. there has been a great deal of conjecture on my behalf. some think it has a subversive twist to it. others imagine that i am absolutely distraught with life and cannot cope anymore. neither extreme really addresses the central issues i have faced. here are a few of the reasons why some of us tend to fade away:

we are tired of pretending that we cannot be hurt. people assume ministers are available for their criticism 24/7. people say things to clergy they would not say to their worst enemies. for some reason they feel at liberty to delve into every aspect of clergy life. they have an opinion about everything we do. they believe it is their god-given right to critique your personal life, your professional life, your emotional state, the way you dress, your use of colloquialisms, your kids, your personality, how much you spend on a car, your friendships, how you drive, how much you fart, the list goes on and on. pastors live their life in the limelight. they, therefore, constantly disappoint people. it is hard to disappoint people all the time. as a pastor, and maybe it is just me, i seem to let people down all the time. recently i was at a small group where several complained that i was not their close friend. besides the obvious fact that i do not have enough hours in the day nor the emotional energy to be friends with everyone, let alone friendly, how can you assume i would would want to be your close friend? ministers spend their entire life pretending to like a portion of the population that they really cannot stand…

pastors tend to build up that insecurity the longer they work. they feel the pressure to put numbers on the role, they also realize that people leave the church because of them. that is a heady responsibility to bear. they understand that people don't like them but it still hurts when they have people they have invested in leave the church because of them. this life can be an exercise in guilty and humility. everything that happens which is good is "to god be the glory" ...they know who is to blame if things go bad. add to this that for some reason many churches rise and fall on the health and exuberance of their pastor. after a while pastors tend to jump from one quick fix solution to another in a desperate bid to patch holes that are systemic and often metaphysical. they attend conferences and clinics designed to point out their flaws and obvious solutions. they quickly conclude that they are the problem, the issue, and the solution. they develop a messiah complex. they develop an insecurity complex…

ministers are normal people who struggle with laziness and workaholism at the same time. no one knows what they do during the week so they tend to strive too hard to be noticed or duck out when they can get away with it. they realize that some volunteers do more than they do and it drives them crazy. they vassalate between the drive to do everything and the need to let others do the work of the church. they are control freaks, often out of necessity. sometimes out of ego need.

oh ya, and we love to be compared. compared to huge churches with massive budgets and incredible bands. compared to tv evangelists who spend more on dog food than we will see in a year. compared to amazing speakers, incredible entrepeneurs, and holy monkish nerds who can pray more than we can. that kind of stuff makes us very content.

ya this is a whine but it's my blog and you don't have to read it. perhaps, though, there may be a grain of truth in what you have read. take a look at your pastor if you have one. listen to his or her brokenness strewn in amongst the exterior confidence. let them know you don't need anything from them. shut up about them when others encourage you to spill. tell someone else to shut up occasionally. don't phone them on mondays. don't critique the way they dress when they go to the bank on their day off. don't act amazed when they stumble. we all stumble.

but for God's sake, don't feel sorry for them. they chose this life and it has incredible rewards. just pay them more.

and oh ya, they won't believe you when you praise them but they will obsess when you criticize them. sounds like quite a great life huh? makes you want to join right up i bet...

as for me, i'm just taking a break to get out of the fishbowl for a while. it's a calling - a blessing and a curse. of course now i have to get a real job where people have to get up every morning and put in 8 hours and pretend to care about stuff i never imagined caring about before.�

What are your thoughts?


This post has been viewed 544 times so far.


 TRACKBACKS: (0) There are 110 Comments:

  • Posted by

    Pastors in pain! I feel for you BIG time.

    The author writes “and oh ya, they won’t believe you when you praise them but they will obsess when you criticize them. sounds like quite a great life huh? makes you want to join right up i bet...”

    YES. Sometimes I think there’s something wrong with me, because I do deflect the praise but obsess over the criticism.

    Those of you who are NOT in ministry full-time who are critical of the pastors in pain who have posted here… Please… consider the possibility that you do NOT know the kind of emotional stress they’re involved in. I have worked in both part-time volunteer ministry and in full-time staff ministry.

    When you’re a pastor it is AMAZING the kind of mean criticism you will receive that you would never hear if you were a volunteer. Trust us who know from experience if you don’t…

  • Posted by

    My parents are visiting with us right now and I mentioned this post to my father and asked him if he had ever thought of leaving the ministry. His reply “There were times in the 45 years of being a pastor that I thought of leaving a particular church but never the ministry.”
    It nearly brought tears to my eyes. What a wonderful example he has set because I know it hasn’t always been easy and in fact growing up becoming a pastor was the last thing in the world that I ever wanted to be. If he could make it through 45 years of low pay, angry people, stuberan leaders, and ungrateful parisheners I think I should be able to make it a few more days.

    Thanks dad and all those other men and women who have served faithfully in the church without becoming bitter or angry at God or the people. Your example gives me hope.

  • Posted by

    I have to say that we fully understand and could have written those exact words!!
    My husband has just exactly one week ago today resigned from his position of Senior Pastor. We could not take another day of dissapointment, pain or attack from others.
    After sacrificing everything, our family life, finances, jobs, enough was enough.
    I watched him suffer extraordinary stress working his secular job, trying to run the church, putting up with judgement and criticism from some after he gave more than he had to give and devoted his time and energy willingly and lovingly to others needs.
    It was time to move on, we are not bitter but we do wonder what it was all about. We know we have helped many according to the way we should have and many lives have been changed but in the end we could no longer bare the pain and endure the hard work of doing it all because no one else really wanted to help. 
    Are we failures, NO I don’t believe any of us are. We are all worth something, some may serve half heartedly for many years and some of us give everything we have and more for even a short time.
    So what now ...a long holiday...haven’t had one in almost six years.
    Myself, go back to work and catch up with life, have some privacy and not have my life examined under a microscope by anyone anymore...my husband ..work five days a week (instead of four) at his trade where there is no comparible stress and live life for ourselves. Yes we will fellowship somewhere in the future but all I can say is until you have been there it is difficult to understand and some, even other Pastors should not judge what we have done or what others have been through.
    I believe our God is bigger than it all and He has wonderful plans for our future and the lives of other (ex)ministers.
    Ministry never ends, but it begins at home first.

  • Posted by

    I have read though all 103 comments to this post and I am still stunned. Stunned at the response which speaks to the enormity of the issue. Stunned at the open honesty of so many of the responders, and stunned at the critical comments made to those who have served and cannot do it anymore. While we are sinners and will fail and fall in so many ways until Jesus comes, it is incomprehensible that those called to serve the church of Christ should find that their greatest threat comes from those they call brother and sister. I know Paul faced the same thing especially from the church in Corinth, but haven’t we learned anything?

    It is one thing not to be paid well. Some churches just do not have the resources and it is out of their control. You can survive with inadequate pay but be beloved. But to be constantly criticized for anything and everything is just wrong. It is none of their business. Church that have this pattern don’t deserve another pastor to devour. They ought to know better. Those toxic church need to be quarantined so they harm another family.

    I am stunned.

  • Posted by

    Kent,

    You’re right. It’s surprising and disturbing! Let’s all take a moment (I’m going to go outside in the sunshine for a few minutes to do this) to lift up all these hurting brothers and sisters in prayer. In any given week I can have emotional and spiritual highs and lows that are both higher and WAY lower than when I was in secular work and volunteered at a church instead of working at one. So I understand what those guys (and gals) are saying. I’m sure my wife does, too…

    By the way, I wonder if it’s not “toxic churches” as much as toxic PEOPLE. We can all be toxic sometimes…

  • Posted by

    I wish I had time to read everyone’s response right now, but I don’t.  Scott’s pain resonates deep in my own soul.  I have a calling to minister to pastors who hurt like this.  I am also writing a book on caring for pastors.  God is preparing me to walk the path of a pastor so I will be better equipped to minister to them.  I am in seminary & a youth minister presently.  I fight these same emotions in my context right now.  I accept the responsibility to guard my senior pastor and yet, I receive the same kind of criticisms (on a smaller scale) in my own situation.  I continue to whine to God saying that I am simply not “thick-skinned” enough to even think that I could effectively pastor.  I am so totally dependent on God.  I hate to see people suffer like Scott & I know that so many do.  I can’t describe the pain I feel inside for them.  I empathize so much because I saw a pastor persecuted so badly once and I’ve never forgotten it.  I’d like to educate laity on having a more realistic perception of a pastor, so that God’s grace is exercised when they stumble in the fishbowl.  I pray for God to use me to make a difference in this somehow.  I want to help so many more than just my pastor.  I believe God has a greater plan in God’s time, but I have a sense of urgency about it all.  I’ll be praying for you, Scott, for I know God will heal you as you take a break away.  I can’t help feeling that you are a great pastor & God will get you back into the game after you’ve had some time to rest.  You are simply being renewed in God’s strength.

  • Posted by kc

    The other day I heard a pastor, (not my pastor) from the central part of my state, preach a lifeless, passionless, pointless sermon with no power and no fire.  I am not referring to animated “aerobic exercise classâ€? preaching. (Vance Havner, a great man of God, preached with power and passion and fire yet he was not animated but monotone and motionless in his preaching style.) The message I heard the other day was a waste of my time and that provokes me to say the following to our preachers:

    We are thirsty and we are hungry. We are hurting and we need help. We need the fire of God and we need the power of God. And preacher, we need you.

    You have a special calling upon your life and God has chosen you to be His voice.

    But what we don’t need are more cute alliterated sermons, as helpful as alliteration can be in communicating a message. What we don’t need are more sermons that have three points, six sub-points, and a cute, closing story or poem, as helpful as that may be in communicating a message. What we don’t need are more funny, silly jokes in sermons. What we don’t need is for you to keep referring to yourself when you preach. And what we don’t need is to hear more sermons from the internet or from some book that was purchased at the latest Christian book store sale.

    What we need is for our preachers to have the fire of God. What we need is for our preachers to have the power of God. What we need is for our preachers to have a passion for the messages that are proclaimed. What we need is for our preachers to feed us from the written Word of God and then to point us to the Living Word of God. What we need is for our preachers to be consumed by fire from heaven so that we, ourselves, may join you in being consumed by God. What we need is for our preachers to be consumed by their passion for the Word of God. 

    Please help us, preachers. We know that we have a personal responsibility for our own walk with God. But we need help. We are weak, we are frail, and we are forgetful. We need to hear from heaven. We don’t need to hear about fishing trips or cruises in sermons. We don’t need more covered dish suppers at the church. We don’t need to hear about the local football team in messages that are preached. We don’t need to hear of accomplishments and awards and degrees. What we want to hear is that you have been approved by God to proclaim His Word to us. 

    We are perishing in the pews and we perish because there is little or no vision of God in some of our pulpits. We are tired of hearing Proverbs 29:18 misinterpreted and applied to long-range planning. We, the people, are perishing because there is no vision of God.

    Rise up! Stand up! And don’t settle for mediocrity! Don’t settle for less! Get all that you can get from God, give it to us, and then go back and get some more. Pursue God with passion. Don’t go into the pulpit until you have a message from Him to proclaim to us. Don’t preach until you know that you are right with God. Don’t go into the pulpit until you know you are anointed by God and have the fire of God.

    Yours and His,

    Kenny

    P.S. It has been said that where there is smoke there is fire. And where there is fire there is an attraction and attention to the fire. But sadly, though, smoke can also be an indication that the fire has gone out.

  • Posted by

    Pastoring is hard.  Just like many other callings in life.  I feel for the pastors who have expressed their difficulties, but how much does whining really help.  I am most likely about to be asked to leave my current pastorate because I moved the pulpit and stopped wearing a tie without asking permission.  That is church life (unfortunately).  I think we need to spend less energy whining about how bad pastors are treated and start figuring out how the church got this way.

  • Posted by

    I too left the ministry for the same reasons… but not from the congregation, but the other pastors and leadership team. It is important that as pastors you want encouragement and respect and not being under the microscope to your congregation, that you offer the same to your support staff or those pastors under you. I actually received all those harsh treatments and words from the pastors, not the congregation. I saw such a double standard and the pastors only working very little requiring a ton from support or lesser roles, as “leadership team” went jogging together and lunches constantly, while we were left to do our roles, talk about lack of encouragement or support. I know this is a “poor pastors” blog, but sometimes pastors are the very ones turning people off from the church and giving God a bad name. I aprreciate the all the hardships pastors face, but it wasn’t any less in my “lesser role” just had the added criticism of the pastor too…

  • Posted by

    This was an awesome observation of the life of a Pastor. As a Pastors wife , I understand why you feel you need a reprieve from Pastoring.  I believe we all have days that lead us to the same conclusion...Just QUIT....Prayerfully the Lord will revive you and you will once again get back in the saddle and save a lost soul.  In ministry you have to know that your only purpose and your main goal is to win a dying soul to Christ. If you are doing it for any other reason you will falter and lose sight of where God intended for you to be.  There is a soul that is lost and you may be the only one that will win that soul to Christ.
    When man fails to honor and care for their spiriutal leader, remember that the Lord has not forgotten your labor of love. My prayers are with you and your family.

  • Page 5 of 5 pages

    « First  <  3 4 5
Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: