Daily Innovation, Ministry Insights, and Thoughts from Todd Rhoades for Pastors and Church Leaders

HOME | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES | RSS | FORUMS | RESOURCES | SUBMIT CONTENT | TRANSLATE MMI | CONTACT US


Email Newsletter  

Each Monday Morning, we'll send you the newest church leadership headlines straight to your in-box! It's all free and you can unsubscribe at any time! Join over 12,000 other pastors who receive MMI updates each week! We respect your privacy.

image

Immanuel Church, 1906 - 1963 (Changing Your Church Without Killing It)

I couldn't believe it. It was obvious this church building had been built with a deep desire to honor God and help people. Yet something had gone horribly wrong. It was now abandoned, boarded up, and left as a symbol of disappointment and shattered dreams. As was typical for many older churches, there was a cemetery on the church property. But what wasn't typical is that they buried their church! Literally! The gravestone reads: Immanuel Church, 1906 - 1963...

How surreal. The church is supposed to be a place that gives evidence to the resurrection power of Jesus Christ; where people find new life and hope. It’s supposed to overcome death and destruction not submit to it.

Yet they aren’t alone. Although you won’t often find the blatant honesty of the people of Immanuel Church, many churches are dead or dying these days. They aren’t reaching any new people with the hope of Christ. Though churches are in possession of the most profound, exciting, needed, and life changing truth the world has ever known, many of them present this truth in a way that’s superficial and boring.

We’ve all been there, haven’t we? We go, expecting life, only to be bored to tears. Because of this, most people have concluded that church has nothing to offer them. If it isn’t going to strengthen, inspire, and fill them with hope, why would they attend?

I believe that the church is the hope of the world, with this one caveat.when it’s working right. And, there in lies the problem. Most aren’t! But there is hope. The reality is that even the most irrelevant, boring, dying church can become relevant and revitalized. But to do so, they must change-which is never easy.

TAKING FLIGHT
For years, I talked about skydiving. Then a guy started attending our church that did it regularly. When he heard me talking, he thought I was serious and invited me to go with him. All of a sudden I knew the truth: I liked talking about jumping, but I really wasn’t interested in actually doing it. If I had been, I would have done something about it already. But my fear of losing face proved to be stronger than my fear of jumping. We set the date, and the date arrived. Though I looked for a legitimate way out, I couldn’t find one. On the outside, I was exuding confidence. On the inside, I was questioning my sanity and looking carefully at my life insurance policy.

As I got on the plane, I plastered a smile on my face and put both thumbs up in the air, but I felt like a lamb being led to the slaughter. Finally, we were at altitude. The regular and experienced divers jumped first. I remember watching in amazement. The guy from our church jumped out backwards and did a flip. Then it was my turn. We inched to the door. “One, two, three,” and my partner pushed me out the door. Though initially leaving the safety of the plane was scary, it was the last bit of fear I remember. From then on, it was pure exhilaration. Then, when the chute opened, it transformed the experience from a seemingly out of control frenzy to one of the most peaceful, quiet moments that I’ve experienced. From beginning to end, it was an unbelievable event.

Though it may seem like an odd comparison, the experience of change is a lot like my skydiving experience for most people. Though it’s easy for people to talk about, most are fearful about going through it.

LIMIT THE CHANGES
To effectively help people process change, the number of changes must be limited. Everything cannot be changed at once. The good news is that everything doesn’t need to be changed at once. In any given church, no matter how bad things may be, there are usually only a couple of issues hurting and hindering the church significantly. Most church transitions experience difficulty because the leaders either change too many things at one time or they change the wrong things. For a successful transition, leaders must identify those key issues and move forward slowly but steadily.

This is the path I took in the church I now pastor. In our journey from irrelevant to relevant, bound by tradition to freed by God’s truth, unhealthy to healthy, dying to thriving, we learned a lot.much of it the hard way. God has allowed us to experience our transition in order to provide help and hope to Christians who know in their hearts that something is desperately wrong with their church; for pastors, leaders, and churches wanting to fulfill God’s purpose in the world again; and for skeptics and seekers who, whether they know it or not, are desperately looking for God and His hope. . . which means they desperately need a church that’s working right.

While it’s true that many churches are dead or dying, it is equally true that they don’t have to stay that way. Your church can successfully change without compromise.

Reprinted by permission. Change Your Church for Good, Brad Powell, 2007, Thomas Nelson Inc. Nashville, Tenn. All rights reserved.

Detailed information on the conference Change Without Compromise ( February 8-10, 2007 ) is available at www.ChurchDare.com - And you can get more information on Brad’s new book, “The Art of Sacred Cow Tipping:  Change Your Church for Good” at BradPowellonline.com.

Brad Powell is the Senior Pastor of NorthRidge Church. Under Brad’s leadership for the past 16 years, NorthRidge Church has transitioned from a dying church locked in a pattern of cultural irrelevance, to an exciting, contemporary church communicating God’s Word to people from every generation. Brad is a frequent conference speaker, and provides leadership resources and encouragement for other churches in transition through NorthRidge Ministries Association and an annual conference, Change Without Compromise. Brad’s new book, “Change Your Church for Good: The Art of Sacred Cow Tipping”, is scheduled for release from Thomas Nelson Publishing in January 2007. He and his wife, Roxann, have been married for 27 years and have three adult children.

- - - - - - - - - -

This post has been viewed 1390 times and was added on January 15, 2007 by Todd Rhoades.
Filed under:
Share this post with a friend right now!
View reactions to this post at other blogs...

You can really help us out by subscribing to our free RSS feed with your favorite feed reader, or here at Bloglines. Also, you can add us to your favorites at Technorati.


It's easy...
Link to this URL


Like this article? Get our free weekly email newsletter for more great resources just like this...  



- - - - - - - - - -
  There are 17 Comments:
  • Posted by

    I love change! But I ain’t skydivin’!

  • Posted by

    Love the article!  Part of what is not addressed however is when senior leadership (i.e. Senior Pastor and Deacons) are unwilling or unable to start change even as they admit we need it to stop and turn around the process of dying.  I think (gulp!) I would like to try skydiving, though I am afraid of heights.

  • Posted by

    James, yes what do we do when the elders (along with the Pastor, who is one of the elders) recognize change is needed and develop a plan to initiate change and then after a few vocal members of the congregation express unwillingness to change direction, the Pastor backs off and says that the elders need to do what the congregation (or at least the vocal naysayers) want?

    Elder Rick

  • Often times we church people are like infants ...

    We cry because we need changed ... 
    Sometimes the church resembles Noah’s Ark.  If it wasn’t for the storm on the outside we would not be able to withstand the stink on the inside!

    We cry during the changing process ...
    The change process can be ugly, embarrassing, stinky, and most definately uncomfortable.  Personalities flare, anger presents, and friendships are tested.  We often forget that we are on the same side.  Often times like two porcupines in a snow storm...we know we need the warmth of one another but we forget to drop our quills and end up getting poked and jabbed.

    Often times we cry after we’ve experienced change…
    Some times after its all said and done, change requires a grieving and healing period.  If we fail to address the emotional and relational impact of change through a planned recovery period the wounded soldiers many never be able to regroup and march into battle again.

  • I am always looking for ways to enhance the ministry at Emmanuel.  I agree with Brad, most of the time it should be one step at a time, but a step that has been thorughly prayed about, discussed, and and investigated to make as sure as possible that it is the right thing to do.  To have a zeal to keep things fresh and alive is a good thing.

  • Posted by

    Rick, I wish I knew that.  It seems to me that we shouldn’t be so concerned with a few vocal naysayers, but more concerned with what God is doing.  If we don’t follow His leadership then we will be left behind and He will use others to accomplish His purpose.  I am a 2nd chair leader in the church I am currently serving in (not that I am listened to) and I must follow what the pastor does even if it makes no sense to me.  I always fall back on the only thing I can do that makes the most difference and that is to pray for the SP and the other leaders and, even, for those few vocal naysayers.

  • Posted by Rick White

    I’m probably in the minority here, but I don’t see that closing a church’s doors has to be negative...or a repudiation of the life we’re given in Jesus.  God told man to be fruitful and multiply.  People die...but humanity lives on because we obey that one mandate to fruitful and multiply. 

    The church is a living, spiritual body.  I wonder what would happen if we actually took multiplication seriously?  If people didn’t multiply, death would be so much harder to deal with...and so much more tragic (anyone see the movie “Children of Men”?--great example). 

    Anyway...I think we consider a dying church “tragic” because there’s not much multiplying going on in the church world...cloning, maybe...but not multiplying.  We’re either impotent churches...or churches that have chosen to not have children.  Both scenarios provide a picture of the real tragedy when a church closes its doors.

  • Posted by Norm

    In response to Rick White’s comments. As I was reading Rick’s response I was reminded of folks who go to great lengths to keep a family member on life support and other measures after being assured there was no chance of their loved one surviving. It is like we can’t let go. Sometimes I guess it could be the same in a church’s life. We don’t want to give up even though death has been determined becasue we somehow feel it would be wrong to give up.

  • Posted by

    "but I don’t see that closing a church’s doors has to be negative...”

    Totally agree, Rick. Some day God will end the ministry I’m doing on earth. That will be just fine! It will fulfill its purpose in its time…

  • Posted by

    It all comes down to what a church is, “organism” , verses what a church does ,"organization". When the “is” becomes clouded by the “does”, the church will linger on, but ultimately die a slow death.  I sometimes wonder if God doesn’t just send a few loonies along to put a church out of its misery.  Probably the better measure of a community is not how many churches are out of business, but how many bars and brothels are.  We are the people of God, and buildings are only temporary tools anyway. Church buildings don’t just die on their own, people either lose heart, lose hope, or become irrelevant to their community.

  • Posted by Leonard

    All organisms have a life cycle.  Who says the life cycle of a local church has to be 100’s of years?  I would rather see a church have 10 great years than 5 good ones followed by 50 mediocre ones. 

    As for change.  Many leaders try to win the margins and lose the trust of the whole.  80% of the people are going to move along with change pretty well while the rest on the margins will resist.  As a leader I try to lead the middle and stay respectful of the margins.  Every year we set a couple days aside as a church to answer three questions.  What will we do as a church to reach un-churched people for Christ?  What will we do as a church this year to help people deepen their friendship with God and finally; What will we do as a church this year to develop leaders and the gifts of our people this year. When we find these answers we find our goals.  These goals become owned by a group of people, almost all from the middle.  My job as a leader is then to strengthen the middle by empowering them to accomplish the goals. 

    I also speak of change as the norm in our church.  This helps us think in experiment and risk.

  • Posted by

    Thanks for the reminder. Sometimes change is hard because we cannot overcome our fears(as in the skydiving example). Change is inevitable, My prayer is that the change is for positive growth and not for the negative. I saw a short video that talked about how the grocery store, and the community changed over the decades, but not the church. The grocery store continued to meet the needs but the church did not. Many times we wait too long to make changes. Churches are like any organization, there is a bell curve to them. If we do not effect change before the pentacle of the curve we are already too late. We as church leaders must follow the Lord’s leading and not those in the pew.

  • Posted by

    Dear Friends
    Wonderful insight as always..  the only problem I see is what is implied to as “the church” is a lifeless buildiing made of wood, steel or concrete. As I recall from some of my reading of the Bible, the people inside the building is the church!  Are we in the mode of prophecy and actually seeing the Christians of America dying as well???  Remember the little game with hand position where the rhyme goes (with the fingers outside of the hand) “here’s the church, heres the steeple, open the door where are all the people?” When the note was made about ‘organisms” dying, I wonder if Jesus envisioned (well of course He did) the death of His church.  Maybe the leaders of ALL the denominations need to review their policies in relation to Revelation 1:11 - 3:22 before it is too late.  And we are truly caught sleeping and religions such as Islam, Universal Unitarinism, Mormonism, secularism such as dollarism, sportsism, couch potatoism and other such eastern cults over come is choke the life out us those few who strive to have the world know the only true Salvation!
    have a good week - on our knees

  • Posted by

    I’ve seen a number of churches that were already dead.  The Spirit had left the body and all that was left was the shell.  No one had the nerve to “pull the plug”.  I think it’s better for some churches to die so that the members are forced to go and find a healthy, living, vibrant church where they can be nurtured. Some churches are just religious museums—full of relics and history but nothing living.  Sick churches are like sick people—some can be recusitated and some cannot.

  • Posted by

    That is so true.  I think about the church I am currently serving in...sometimes I feel as if I am doing hospice ministry.  I don’t think this is what God wants for His church…

  • Posted by

    Enjoyed the article. It seems to be the story heard time and time again. Seeing the need for change and knowing how to process the changes are totally different. Every church has personality and that personality dictates how change should be implimented. Then there are times that people are just unwilling to change, even though it mean certain death.
    Skydiving, had to do once in the service (actually was forced out of the plane if the truth were known) and jumping out of perfectly good airplanes makes no sense whatsoever.

  • Posted by

    Anyone have any info on the Immanuel Church that is referred to at the top? Location, history, etc?

  • Page 1 of 1 pages

Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: