HOME | CONTRIBUTE A STORY! | ABOUT MMI | CATEGORIES OF INTEREST | CONTACT ME


image

Willow:  We Got it All Wrong

Orginally published on Monday, October 22, 2007 at 6:37 AM
by Todd Rhoades

Willow has recently asked the question, "Is what we are doing as a church helping people achieve intimacy with Christ?" Their answer... in many cases, was no. You may have heard of the Willow "Reveal Study". Now you can watch Willow XP Greg Hawkins talk about what Willow thinks they've learned through the study. Where did they go wrong? What did they have right?

Watch the Video here...

Then, I’d love to hear your comments.  I’ve heard a lot of people talk about the Willow Study.  The reactions have been everything from ‘wow, this is great stuff’ to ‘well, duh’!  What’s your take?


This post has been viewed 2957 times so far.


  There are 24 Comments:

  • Posted by

    As an infant, you have to take little steps first, guided by a parent, in order to master the concept of walking.This is also true in the spritual realm. In order for intimacy to develop, you have to develop the thought that something has been done for you in life or else your prospective on intimacy can be extremely shallow. In other words your meaning of intimacy will be empty because you won’t know “ why “ you feel the way you do.
    After visiting Willowcreek when I use to live in Illinois, I noticed that no one ever conveyed to me during that service that Christ loved me so much, it took everything he had ( death, burial, and resurrection; 1 Cor 15:3,4,) in order to give me intimacy with him (Christ). By acknowledging Christ, who took away all my past, present and future sins, and giving me the hope of eternal life, I can very much appreciate intimacy with him, because now I know something was done for me at the cross long ago! Getting back to Willowcreek, I ask the question “… how shall they know without a preacher....?” ( one who preaches the good news of Jesus Christ?) Intimacy with Christ otherwise is shallow and you will always think something is wrong and you will always strive with questions on finding intimacy.

  • Posted by Tim Bednar

    I found the video by Greg very honest. The out of Ur blog post might have been a bit hyped though…

    I wrote a post on how church software re-enforces the “participation” model for measuring success. This is the model Willow Creek uses and found lacking.

    Basically, the tools we use to “manage” the church work against the findings Willow Creek’s study revealed.

    http://blog.plaidfile.com/tags/tips/how-plaid-answers-the-challenge-issued-by-the-new-book-from-greg-hawkins-and-cally-parkinson-of-willow-creek/

  • Posted by Mark Howell

    An important insight into Willow’s research is the fact that the findings in Reveal: Where Are You? are based on 5000 responses by Willow Creek attendees.  Good enough to give statistical accuracy...but only if it is a representative cross section of who attends.  The book acknowledges the fact that 85% of the 5000 attend 3 to 4 times a month.  That doesn’t sound at all representative to me.  While the data is informative, it is skewed significantly toward the attitudes of their most mature attendees.

  • Posted by Peter Hamm

    Mark,

    Not only that, but the study was, at that point, ONLY Willow Creek. They are about to expand this study to other churches. We are fortunate enough to be part of that. I can’t wait to see what we’re doing “wrong”!

    They are working very hard to turn this study into something useful, not just for them, but for any church remotely like them.

  • Posted by Mark Howell

    Actually, Reveal included the results from 7 additional congregations as well.  But, the largest sample was Willow’s own.  It will be interesting to see what is learned from the larger sample being gathered right now.

  • Posted by Camey

    What continues to strike me about this is the fact they are even willing to admit they were wrong… or might be wrong.

    Let’s face it. How many churches do things wrong, know it, and keep on keeping on thinking they are “saving face” or doing their members/attenders a favor?

  • Posted by

    Praise God Willow Creek has some back bone and humility to admit it.

  • Posted by

    I’ve always been impressed with Bill Hybels and now am even more so. 

    I like his willingness to even talk about the possibility!

  • Posted by

    I appreciate the honesty and openness of this: Greg says that “the people who love God the most are the most disappointed by their local church”.  The sad truth is that this is indeed happening as we witness a shift in dynamics as many churches are discussing new models, approaches and ways of “doing church”.  Therein lies the problem.  We need to forget about how we “do” church and start “being” the church.  It seems we have forgotten what it means to be the Body of Christ in the world today.  See God’s Wake up Call to the Church - By Wayne J. Edwards
    http://www.prophezine.com/PZArticles/GodsWakeupCalltotheChurch/tabid/510/Default.aspx

  • Posted by

    You are so right Tony.  It’s time to forget about “doing church” with all it’s antics and start “being the church”.

  • Posted by Peter Hamm

    You’d all love the T-shirts we made for a recent event. Says “I don’t go to church” on the front and “I am the church” on the back.

  • Posted by

    It looks like Willow Creek is still heading down a troubling path. At their upcoming 2008 “Shift” conference at Willow Creek for young people, Bill Hybels is featuring apostate Brian McLaren as keynote speaker.

  • Posted by Camey

    We just got the REVEAL book. There are a few lines on the back cover that really strike a chord with us:

    “Numbers can be helpful, but they don’t reveal the whole story. Numbers can’t peer into the human heart.”

    We’re trying to not fight over who is reading it first. Ah..... change.. It’s in the air.

  • Posted by

    Too often we forget that Christ spen 3 1/2 years mentoring his disciples. We baptize people then leave them to thir own resourses to fin how to grow in Christ. We leave them on their own to discover their spiritual gift (s). We leave them on their own to find a ministry that they can excl at within the church.

    All of this seems backwards from the way Christ did it. Doesn’t it?

  • Posted by PMI-001

    What i obesereved actually, Reveal is included the results from the 7 additional congregations as well.  i am agree with the Mark Comments. Yep, i am agree that the largest sample was Willow’s own.  Lets see now who has the largest Sample now onwards smile
    220-602 - 1Y0-259

  • It reminds me of politicians who change their views and how they say things just to suit what people want to hear. But, you also have to respect Willow’s ability to reinvent itself. Not many churches would be willing to change course in a big way.

    Also, it just makes me wonder if maybe Willow is just entering a different phase in its life cycle. Perhaps it’s like leaving adolescence and entering early adulthood, or something like that? Not to say that one phase is better than another, just different.

  • Posted by Funny SMS

    Nice Stuff.
    Thank you for post.

  • Posted by Jon watson

    I’ve always been impressed with Bill Hybels and now am even more so.

    I like his willingness to even talk about the possibility!
    regards,
    http://www.newhamps.com/

  • Posted by

    The book acknowledges the fact that 85% of the 5000 attend 3 to 4 times a month.  That doesn’t sound at all representative to me.  While the data is informative, it is skewed significantly toward the attitudes of their most mature attendees of Education .
    Thanks

  • Posted by

    Let’s face it. How many churches do things wrong, know it, and keep on keeping on thinking they are “saving face” or doing their members/attenders a favor?
    regards,
    baby shower games

  • Posted by

    Perhaps it’s like leaving adolescence and entering early adulthood, or something like that? Not to say that one phase is better than another, just different.
    regards,
    luggage bags

  • Posted by

    I wrote a post on how church software re-enforces the “participation” model for measuring success. This is the model Willow Creek uses and found lacking.
    regards,
    casino em linha

  • Posted by dll

    Reveal included the results from 7 additional congregations as well.

    But, the largest sample was Willow’s own.  It will be interesting to see what is learned from the larger sample being gathered right now.

  • Posted by vancl

    It looks like Willow Creek is still heading down a troubling path. At their upcoming 2008 “Shift” conference at Willow Creek for young people, Bill Hybels is featuring apostate Brian McLaren as keynote speaker.

    VANCL
    Mobile Games
    Mini Games

  • Page 1 of 1 pages

Post Your Comments:

Name:

Email:

Location:

URL:

Live Comment Preview:

Remember my personal information

Notify me of follow-up comments?

Please enter the word you see in the image below: